Industrial technology regulation faces a persistent challenge: technologies can develop and change faster than conventional rulemaking processes. For automation engineers, system integrators and plant leaders, that gap matters when connected devices, software and artificial intelligence become part of operational systems. A governance approach that can adapt as technologies mature may help address genuine risks without locking in rules based on assumptions that quickly become outdated.
One approach described in technology policy is soft law governance: guidance, voluntary standards and best practices that set expectations without having the direct enforceability of statutes or binding regulations. It offers a way to develop shared practices while regulators, industry and other stakeholders learn more about an emerging technology and its effects.
Why industrial technology regulation is difficult to keep current
Traditional command-and-control regulation is designed to establish requirements through formal processes. Those processes can offer clarity, but they may be difficult to align with technologies whose capabilities and applications are still evolving. When requirements take shape before the relevant risks and uses are well understood, they may fail to address later concerns or constrain beneficial applications.
The challenge is not limited to digital businesses. As software and connected technologies spread into other parts of the economy, manufacturing and other traditionally physical sectors also face questions about how new systems should be governed. The policy guide argues that flexible approaches used in the technology sector could inform oversight in areas such as manufacturing and health care.
For industrial decision-makers, this is a governance issue rather than a substitute for engineering judgment or applicable legal requirements. Plant teams still need to evaluate the systems they deploy and manage operational risks. The policy question is how rules and expectations can evolve without creating unnecessary uncertainty for organizations developing, integrating or adopting new technologies.
How soft law governance works
Soft law can begin in different settings, including industry groups, academic research, government-convened discussions or policy organizations. The resulting recommendations may take the form of guidance, best practices or voluntary standards. In the framework described in the guide, these proposals gain legitimacy through a collaborative process that brings together different stakeholders and seeks a workable degree of consensus.
Those outputs can then follow different paths. They may support voluntary self-regulatory arrangements, or they may inform legislation and binding rules. In this sense, soft law does not rule out formal regulation. It can help develop a shared understanding of an issue before decision-makers determine whether stronger legal requirements are needed.
Multistakeholder engagement is central to the approach. Industry, government, civil society, trade associations and other interested parties can contribute perspectives on how a technology is used, what concerns it raises and which practices may be appropriate. This can make governance more responsive than relying exclusively on a single regulator to define requirements in a fast-changing area.
Potential benefits—and the trade-off of uncertainty
Flexible guidance and voluntary standards can be revised as technologies and their applications change. Collaborative development can also give participants a role in shaping expectations and encourage compromise. For emerging industrial technologies, that adaptability may be useful when the details of future deployments are not yet clear.
But flexibility has a cost. Nonbinding guidance may leave organizations unsure about what regulators will expect, and uncertainty can affect decisions about investment and commercialization. The source highlights the concern that prolonged regulatory ambiguity can increase development costs and time, making commercialization less predictable and, in some cases, difficult to finance.
Soft law therefore should not be treated as a universal answer. Its value depends on whether it creates useful, credible expectations while avoiding the ambiguity that can undermine planning. The task for policymakers is to balance adaptability with enough predictability for organizations to make informed decisions.
Applying the approach to industrial IoT and AI
The Internet of Things is one example of a technology area where governance questions can intersect with industrial operations. Connected devices raise issues involving privacy and cybersecurity, and the guide identifies these as areas for policy consideration. For industrial IoT, the practical implication is that governance discussions should account for the technology’s specific context rather than assume that one fixed rule will fit every application.
Artificial intelligence presents a related challenge because it is a “nexus technology”: advances in AI can affect many other technologies and industries. The guide considers AI in areas including medical devices, digital advertising and algorithmic accountability. Its broader recommendation is to focus oversight on real harms rather than responding to perceived risks alone, while using mechanisms suited to the technology being addressed.
For automation leaders, this supports a measured approach to emerging technology policy:
- Distinguish established risks from speculative concerns. Policy should respond to identifiable problems rather than assume every possible harm will materialize.
- Include affected stakeholders. Engineers, operators, technology providers, regulators and other participants can contribute different views of a system’s use and potential effects.
- Allow expectations to adapt. Guidance and voluntary standards can be revisited as technologies and their applications develop.
- Preserve regulatory options. Voluntary approaches can inform later legislation or binding rules where they are warranted.
Practical implications for technical decision-makers
Plant managers and system integrators do not control the policy environment, but they can pay attention to how expectations are formed. Participation in relevant industry or multistakeholder discussions can help ensure that governance proposals reflect practical contexts, while internal evaluation of connected and AI-enabled systems can help organizations make reasoned deployment decisions.
Policymakers, in turn, can consider whether a new requirement is necessary, whether existing authority can address the concern, and whether flexible guidance would be more appropriate while evidence develops. The guide’s central principle is caution in both directions: avoid rules that unnecessarily restrict innovation, but do not treat flexibility as a reason to ignore demonstrated harms.
Conclusion
Emerging technologies make it difficult to set rules that remain useful as systems and applications change. Soft law governance—through collaborative processes, guidance and voluntary standards—offers one way to create adaptable expectations, including for technologies extending into manufacturing. Its success depends on balancing flexibility with predictability and keeping attention on real risks. For industrial automation leaders, that balance can help support responsible adoption while leaving room for technologies to develop.