For companies that develop or sell complex products—including industrial equipment and automation systems—a patent dispute can raise a difficult damages question: should royalties be calculated on the value of the entire product, or only on the portion attributable to the patented technology? The Federal Circuit’s 2018 decision in Power Integrations v. Fairchild Semiconductor reaffirmed that the entire market value rule remains available, but emphasized how difficult it can be for a patent holder to qualify for it.
The decision matters because products often combine many features, components, and technologies. When a patent covers only one feature, the general principle is that damages should be apportioned to reflect the value of that patented technology—not automatically based on all product revenues.
What the entire market value rule allows
The entire market value rule is an exception to the general requirement to apportion patent damages. It can allow a patent holder to base a reasonable royalty on the value of an entire product when the patented feature is shown to drive demand for that product. The rule is intended to address cases where the patented technology is central to why customers buy the complete apparatus.
Without that showing, the damages analysis must account for the distinction between the patented feature and other parts of the product. Identifying the smallest salable unit that practices the patent does not, by itself, eliminate the need to apportion. The royalty still needs to reflect the value of the claimed technology within that unit.
How the Power Integrations dispute developed
The case followed a jury finding that Fairchild Semiconductor infringed a Power Integrations patent. The jury initially awarded $105 million in reasonable royalties. After that verdict, the Federal Circuit decided VirnetX v. Cisco, reiterating that patent damages generally must be apportioned to patented features, even after a party identifies the smallest salable unit.
Because Power Integrations’ initial royalty calculation did not apportion beyond that unit—and the company had disclaimed reliance on the entire market value rule—the district court ordered a new damages trial. At the second trial, the court excluded the patent holder’s expert testimony based on apportionment but allowed a damages theory based on the entire market value rule. The jury awarded $139.8 million.
In July 2018, the Federal Circuit vacated that award, concluding that Power Integrations had not provided sufficient evidence to invoke the exception. The court’s initial opinion said that, if an accused infringer showed its product had other valuable features, the patent holder had to establish those features were not relevant to consumer choice or did not influence purchasing decisions. Those formulations raised concern because proving that other features played no role in a purchase could be exceptionally difficult.
The revised standard: other features must not cause the purchase
After Power Integrations sought rehearing, the Federal Circuit issued a modified precedential opinion. It revised the wording of the burden: where the accused infringer presents evidence of other valuable features, the patent holder must establish that those features do not cause consumers to purchase the product.
That phrasing appears narrower than requiring proof that other features were irrelevant or had no influence on purchasing decisions. But the practical challenge remains substantial. The relevant question is not simply whether customers value the patented feature; it is whether other valuable features caused them to buy the accused product.
The court indicated that the relevant customers are purchasers of the accused infringer’s product, rather than customers of the patent holder. That distinction can have important discovery implications. A patent holder may need to identify the accused infringer’s customers and seek information from them about their purchasing decisions. Such third-party discovery can be burdensome, and a court may weigh its cost against its likely benefit.
Evidence and unresolved questions
Potential evidence might include customer surveys or information obtained through discovery, but the opinion did not establish a definitive evidentiary formula. It also left open practical questions: How many customers’ purchasing decisions must be examined? Would evidence from a majority be enough, or must the patent holder address every customer? The decision does not resolve those questions.
The opinion also noted that Power Integrations had asserted a second patent directed to another feature. That raises a broader issue for companies with multiple patents covering features in one product. A patent holder may face questions about whether other asserted or marked patents also read on the product, and whether those technologies have value. The decision does not provide a simple answer to how such circumstances affect an attempt to use the entire market value rule.
Why an apportioned damages theory remains important
The practical lesson is not that the entire market value rule has disappeared. Rather, it remains a demanding alternative to the general rule of apportionment. A patent holder seeking damages based on total product value needs evidence connecting the patented feature to demand for the complete product, while anticipating scrutiny of other valuable features.
For businesses involved in patent disputes, the decision underscores the importance of understanding how product features relate to customer purchasing decisions and how the proposed royalty base is supported. It also reinforces the value of preparing a plausible alternative damages analysis that apportions value to the patented technology and the smallest salable patent-practicing unit.
In short, Power Integrations preserved the entire market value rule but did not make it an easy route to broader damages. When a product contains multiple valuable features, a royalty theory tied to the whole product requires persuasive evidence that the patented feature drove demand. Apportionment remains central to a defensible damages analysis, and relying on the exception alone carries significant risk.