A 2019 patent dispute between MLC Intellectual Property and Micron highlighted two consequential questions in damages analysis: how experts may use comparable-license negotiations and how far royalty-base apportionment must go for a single-component semiconductor die.
Articles Tagged: patent damages apportionment
Entire Market Value Rule: Patent Damages and Apportionment
The Federal Circuit’s revised Power Integrations opinion kept the entire market value rule available for patent damages, but left patent holders with a demanding evidentiary burden. The decision highlights why apportionment remains important when a product combines patented technology with other valuable features.
Semiconductor Patent Value: Evidence, Claims and Damages
A semiconductor patent’s practical value depends on more than the novelty of its technology. Claim language, evidence available from finished devices, specification support and the way damages are apportioned can all influence its enforceability and commercial significance.