A federal awards audit brings together financial reporting, grant accounting and compliance oversight. The University of Pennsylvania’s fiscal 2018 report offers a detailed example: it includes audited consolidated financial statements, a Schedule of Expenditures of Federal Awards (SEFA), reports on internal control and compliance, and schedules addressing audit findings and corrective actions. For technical organizations that manage sponsored projects or other regulated funding, the report’s structure helps clarify how these responsibilities are documented and what an audit conclusion does—and does not—mean.
What the federal awards audit covered
The report covers the year ended June 30, 2018, and was issued under the federal Uniform Guidance framework. Its contents are organized into financial reporting, internal control and compliance, findings, and supplementary information. This organization matters: the sections serve related but distinct purposes rather than combining every conclusion into one broad assurance statement.
The independent auditors examined the University’s consolidated financial statements for 2018 and 2017. They concluded that the statements fairly presented, in all material respects, the University’s financial position, changes in net assets and cash flows in accordance with U.S. generally accepted accounting principles. The report also states that management—not the auditors—was responsible for preparing the statements and maintaining relevant internal control.
How sponsored-program costs are recognized
The financial statement notes describe the University’s approach to sponsored programs. Revenue from grants and contracts is generally recognized as the associated direct costs and applicable indirect costs are incurred. Federal indirect-cost recovery is generally based on predetermined reimbursement rates applied to modified total direct costs; rates for other grants and contracts are negotiated with the relevant sponsors.
This accounting approach links the timing and amount of recognized revenue to the costs charged to a project. In practice, that makes complete, supportable accounting records important: reported sponsored-program activity must connect to the underlying transactions and the applicable reimbursement basis. The report notes that sponsored research funds are subject to audit. Management stated that, based on information available at the time, it believed any liability arising from such audits would not materially affect the University’s financial position or operations.
What the SEFA opinion means
The Schedule of Expenditures of Federal Awards is additional analysis required by Uniform Guidance; it is not itself a required component of the consolidated financial statements. For the 2018 schedule, the auditors performed procedures applied in the financial statement audit, along with additional procedures. These included comparing and reconciling schedule information to underlying accounting records or the financial statements.
The auditors concluded that the SEFA was fairly stated, in all material respects, in relation to the consolidated financial statements as a whole. That wording defines the scope of the opinion: it addresses the schedule in relation to the audited statements, not every operational practice or individual transaction in isolation.
The report also distinguishes the SEFA from a supplementary schedule included elsewhere. That supplementary information was not subjected to the audit procedures applied to the financial statements, and the auditors expressly provided no opinion or assurance on it. Readers should therefore check the report’s language for each schedule rather than assume that every included table received the same level of examination.
Internal control reporting is not an effectiveness opinion
The report includes separate reporting under Government Auditing Standards on internal control over financial reporting and on compliance with certain laws, regulations, contracts and grant agreements. The purpose of that work was to describe the scope of testing and its results. The auditors specifically did not express an opinion on the effectiveness of internal control over financial reporting or on compliance.
A related report addresses compliance requirements that could have a direct and material effect on each major program, as well as internal control over compliance, under Uniform Guidance. This separate reporting reflects the difference between testing selected controls and requirements and issuing an overall opinion that a control system is effective. The distinction is useful for anyone interpreting audit reports: a clean financial statement opinion should not be read as a blanket certification of every process.
Why the report’s structure is useful
For organizations managing federally funded work, the report illustrates several practical principles for audit readiness:
- Keep financial reporting and award reporting distinguishable. The consolidated statements and the SEFA serve different reporting purposes, even when they rely on connected accounting records.
- Trace reported amounts to records. The audit procedures described include reconciling schedule information to underlying records or financial statements.
- Understand the basis for cost recovery. Direct costs, applicable indirect costs and negotiated or predetermined rates shape how sponsored-program revenue is recognized.
- Read assurance language precisely. An opinion on financial statements, an opinion on a schedule in relation to those statements, and a report describing control testing are not interchangeable.
The report’s index also lists a schedule of findings and questioned costs, a summary of prior audit findings, and management’s view and corrective action plan. These sections are part of the broader accountability record, alongside the financial statements and compliance reports.
Conclusion
The University of Pennsylvania’s 2018 federal awards audit shows how financial statements, sponsored-program accounting, federal expenditure schedules and compliance reporting fit together while retaining separate scopes. Its central lesson for technical and operational decision-makers is to follow the evidence and the assurance language: know how award costs enter the records, how schedules reconcile, and precisely what each audit conclusion covers. That disciplined reading supports clearer oversight without treating one audit opinion as assurance about every control or compliance obligation.