Groundwater remediation at the Middlefield-Ellis-Whisman (MEW) Superfund Study Area illustrates a challenge familiar to environmental and industrial professionals: a remedy can manage exposure risks while taking many decades to reach its cleanup targets. In its fourth five-year review, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) found that controls at the Mountain View and Moffett Field site were protecting people from current exposure, but that existing groundwater measures were not expected to meet cleanup levels in shallow aquifers for many more decades. That gap has implications for long-term vapor intrusion management.
Why the MEW site requires a regional approach
The MEW study area includes three Superfund sites associated with Fairchild Semiconductor, Raytheon, and Intel, other former industrial facilities, and portions of the former Naval Air Station Moffett Field. Historical industrial and research activities released volatile organic compounds (VOCs), primarily trichloroethene (TCE), to soil and groundwater. Contamination from the different source areas has mixed as groundwater moves generally north toward San Francisco Bay.
Because the plume crosses property and administrative boundaries, cleanup involves multiple parties. The MEW companies address contamination associated with their facility-specific source areas, while regional programs, the Navy, and NASA also operate groundwater systems in their respective areas. The groundwater remedy selected for MEW therefore applies to commingled regional contamination extending onto Moffett Field.
Groundwater is not currently used for drinking in the area. Governmental controls are in place to prevent wells from being installed in contaminated aquifer zones. However, groundwater remains a potential future drinking-water source, which is why cleanup standards apply even while access and exposure are controlled.
Groundwater remediation combines containment and treatment
EPA selected the original soil and groundwater remedy in 1989, later clarifying it through two explanations of significant differences. The soil cleanup involved excavation and treatment, as well as soil vapor extraction with treatment using vapor-phase granular activated carbon. That work was completed in 2001.
For groundwater, the remedy uses extraction and treatment to contain contamination and remove VOCs. Slurry walls—subsurface barriers—help contain contaminated groundwater at selected source areas. Groundwater extraction wells and treatment systems are used across facility-specific and regional areas. Treatment approaches reported in the review include granular activated carbon, air stripping, and oxidation systems. The remedy also calls for maintaining hydraulic gradients within existing slurry walls and preventing contaminated groundwater from migrating into deeper aquifers.
The site’s shallow groundwater system includes several aquifer zones, with deeper aquifers separated by layers that restrict groundwater movement. TCE contamination in the shallow A-zone extends from south of East Middlefield Road northward onto Moffett Field. This shallow contamination is especially relevant because chemicals in groundwater and soil gas can migrate upward and enter buildings.
Vapor intrusion mitigation protects building occupants
EPA added a vapor intrusion remedy in 2010 to address the possibility that TCE and other chemicals could move from subsurface soil or groundwater into indoor air. The response depends on whether a building already exists or is planned for future construction.
- Existing buildings: Indoor air sampling and other evidence are used to determine whether action is needed. Where warranted, a sub-slab or sub-membrane ventilation system is installed, operated, maintained, and monitored. For existing commercial buildings, a mechanical ventilation system may be used if the owner agrees to operate and monitor it in accordance with remedy criteria.
- New construction: Buildings overlying the affected area require a vapor barrier and passive sub-slab ventilation system designed so it can be made active. Monitoring and institutional controls support long-term effectiveness.
By the review period, occupied commercial and non-residential buildings in the Vapor Intrusion Study Area had been sampled. Mitigation or vapor intrusion control systems had been implemented where indoor air exceeded applicable cleanup levels, and systems had been installed in new construction overlying TCE contamination in the shallow zone. Institutional controls also require notification to EPA about certain building improvements that could create a vapor pathway or interfere with an existing remedy.
Why the existing remedy may not meet long-term objectives
EPA’s review found that TCE concentrations in groundwater had declined over time but were leveling off above the cleanup level. The performance of the current groundwater remedy was also declining in effectiveness, and the review concluded that shallow groundwater cleanup levels were unlikely to be achieved for many decades.
This is significant because the vapor intrusion remedy has a second objective beyond protecting occupants with building controls: accelerate reductions in shallow groundwater and soil-gas contamination so that the need for vapor intrusion measures can eventually be minimized or eliminated. A lengthy cleanup timeframe does not align with that objective.
EPA was evaluating alternative groundwater cleanup technologies through a Shallow Zone Focused Feasibility Study. The review describes optimization work, pilot tests, and treatability studies as ongoing, while noting that the long-term performance of these efforts still required assessment. It also identifies questions about contamination extent in some shallow aquifer areas and whether additional groundwater institutional controls would strengthen long-term protection.
Practical implications for site and facility teams
For engineers, system integrators, property owners, and operations teams working at affected sites, the MEW review highlights several practical considerations:
- Groundwater extraction and treatment require ongoing operations, maintenance, and monitoring; system performance must be assessed against both containment and cleanup objectives.
- Groundwater controls alone do not address every exposure pathway. Building sampling, ventilation or sub-slab systems, and construction requirements are integral parts of the remedy.
- Changes to building foundations, ventilation, or other site conditions can affect vapor pathways or existing controls. Required notification and institutional-control procedures should be incorporated into project planning.
- When monitoring indicates that contaminant levels are leveling off above cleanup targets, optimization and evaluation of alternative technologies may be necessary to address long-term objectives.
Conclusion
The 2019 review found the MEW groundwater and vapor intrusion remedies currently protective because direct exposure to contaminated groundwater is controlled and building systems, monitoring, and institutional controls reduce vapor intrusion risks. But current protection is not the same as achieving long-term cleanup goals. The slow progress toward shallow-zone groundwater standards makes evaluation of alternative technologies important—not only for reducing contamination, but also for advancing the objective of reducing reliance on vapor intrusion controls over time.