Innovation growth centers are a proposed way to broaden the geography of technology-led economic activity. The idea responds to a persistent challenge: innovation industries benefit from clustering near specialized workers, firms, suppliers and research institutions, so established hubs can attract still more talent and investment while other metropolitan areas struggle to reach critical mass. A place-based strategy would direct coordinated support to a limited number of promising regions and help them develop into self-sustaining innovation centers.
Why innovation activity concentrates
Innovation industries include highly research- and STEM-intensive activities such as pharmaceuticals, aerospace, semiconductor and communications equipment, software publishing, data services, and scientific research and development. These industries are important to national prosperity and competitiveness, but their economic geography is uneven.
For much of the 20th century, lower costs helped businesses expand in regions where wages and other operating expenses were more affordable. That pattern supported convergence among regions. As innovation and digital technologies became more central to economic activity, however, firms increasingly valued access to specialized talent, knowledge, suppliers and institutions. These advantages are stronger when related organizations are located near one another.
This is known as agglomeration. It can improve productivity through localization economies, which arise when firms in related industries cluster together, and urbanization economies, which come from operating in larger, denser markets with broad labor pools and connections. The result can be cumulative: places with established innovation activity become more attractive to workers and businesses, reinforcing their existing lead.
The whitepaper reports that five leading metropolitan areas—Boston, San Francisco, San Jose, Seattle and San Diego—accounted for more than 90% of U.S. innovation-sector growth from 2005 to 2017. Their combined share of national innovation employment rose from 17.6% to 22.8% over that period. These figures illustrate why regional development cannot be understood simply as a matter of individual firms choosing the lowest-cost location.
What concentration means for companies and regions
Clustering can support valuable innovation ecosystems, but extreme concentration also creates costs. In leading hubs, high housing and real-estate costs, traffic congestion and rising labor expenses can make growth more difficult for workers and employers. Some firms may look elsewhere for expansion, but lower-cost locations outside the United States can compete for that investment when domestic alternatives lack a comparable base of talent and related activity.
Meanwhile, regions with thinner innovation ecosystems may face challenges attracting skilled workers, research activity and new businesses. A limited local pool of relevant employers and suppliers can make it harder to build the relationships that support advanced industries. That gap matters beyond the directly affected metros: nearby towns and communities may have fewer connections to the jobs, supply chains and investment associated with innovation growth.
For industrial companies and automation stakeholders, the regional distribution of innovation capacity also shapes where specialized labor, technical partners and research organizations are available. The issue is not that every city should become a technology hub. Rather, the policy question is whether a carefully chosen group of additional locations could develop enough connected capabilities to offer viable alternatives and broaden access to innovation-led opportunity.
Why local efforts may not be enough
State and local governments can support business development, workforce programs and research partnerships. But the whitepaper argues that these efforts often lack the scale needed to counter self-reinforcing agglomeration. When regions compete for a limited pool of investment and skilled workers, individually useful programs may not be sufficient to create the combined concentration of resources that makes a new hub durable.
Nor does relying on worker migration resolve every concern. Moving to an established innovation center may not be practical or desirable for people with strong ties to their communities, and leading hubs can already face significant costs and infrastructure pressures. The proposed response is therefore place-based: build capacity in selected regions rather than expecting people and businesses alone to correct geographic imbalances.
How an innovation growth-center strategy could work
The proposal calls for a competitive federal program to select eight to 10 metropolitan areas, located away from existing successful tech hubs, for substantial support over 10 years. The objective would be to help promising locations get over the threshold to self-sustaining innovation-sector growth. The approach is selective by design; it does not assume that every region can or should become an advanced-industry center.
Coordinate the inputs needed for scale
Rather than treating research funding, workforce development or urban development as isolated tools, the proposal brings multiple forms of support together. These could include:
- Increased support for scientific and engineering research and development.
- Workforce development, business financing and economic inclusion measures.
- Tax and regulatory supports, along with federal land and infrastructure resources.
- Investment in placemaking, including mixed-use downtowns, waterfront areas and innovation districts.
The paper estimates that direct research and development funding could reach up to $700 million annually in each selected metro area for 10 years. It also gives a rough program-wide estimate of about $100 billion over a decade for 10 centers. These are proposal estimates, not guarantees of funding or outcomes. The underlying principle is that a coordinated package may have more impact than scattered, disconnected interventions.
Use a rigorous selection process
Selection would be based on a competitive process, including a request for proposals, goal-oriented criteria and independent review. Candidate regions would need to demonstrate credible readiness and strengths that could support growth. A fair, transparent process would help direct resources to places with potential rather than distributing support without a clear strategy.
The whitepaper identifies dozens of possible candidates across multiple regions, while emphasizing that final selection should depend on demonstrated capabilities and a rigorous competition. Regional strengths, existing institutions and the ability to turn investment into durable partnerships would be central considerations.
Practical implications for industry leaders
For plant managers, system integrators, operations leaders and technical decision-makers, the growth-center concept highlights the importance of regional ecosystems to industrial innovation. A stronger local base of research institutions, technical workers and advanced-industry businesses can support connections among employers, suppliers and training organizations. The proposal also recognizes that benefits may reach beyond a designated metro through commuting, supply-chain relationships and other regional interdependencies.
However, public investment alone would not ensure that a hub becomes self-sustaining. The intended result depends on selecting places with credible foundations and aligning research, skills, business development and the built environment around shared goals. The strategy is also only one component of a broader response to regional inequality; it is not presented as a complete remedy for struggling cities, smaller towns or rural communities.
Conclusion: build capacity where it can take root
Innovation growth centers offer a targeted response to the concentration of high-tech industries in a small number of metropolitan areas. The proposal rests on a practical observation: when agglomeration advantages compound, market forces and local initiatives may not be enough to create new centers elsewhere. A time-limited, competitive federal effort could help selected regions assemble the research, workforce, business and place-based assets needed to reach critical mass.
For industry, the wider implication is that innovation capacity depends not only on individual firms but also on the networks and institutions around them. Carefully chosen regional investments could create more locations where advanced businesses and technical talent can connect, while extending potential benefits to surrounding communities. Whether such a strategy succeeds would depend on disciplined selection, coordinated support and a clear focus on building lasting regional capability.