Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Integrated resource planning (IRP) is a way to compare potential electricity supply resources on a consistent basis. For engineers, system integrators, plant managers, and energy decision-makers, that comparison involves more than nameplate capacity or equipment price. Performance, operating flexibility, maintenance costs, interconnection needs, and project schedules all affect how a resource may fit into a future portfolio.

A 2018 Puget Sound Energy planning assessment, prepared with HDR Engineering, developed conceptual inputs for thermal generation, renewables, and energy storage. Its central planning lesson remains useful: resource comparisons are only meaningful when assumptions and boundaries are made clear. The estimates were intended for modeling and comparative planning—not as project budgets or guarantees of as-built performance.

What integrated resource planning compares

The assessment considered natural gas-fired combustion turbines and reciprocating internal combustion engines (RICE), combined-cycle generation, onshore and offshore wind, solar photovoltaic (PV), biomass, pumped hydro energy storage (PHES), and battery energy storage systems (BESS). The options were represented by generic technology types and proxy locations rather than a specific proposed project.

For each resource, the planning inputs covered several dimensions:

  • Performance: Net output and efficiency, along with operating characteristics relevant to generation or storage.
  • Capital cost: Conceptual engineering, procurement, and construction (EPC) costs, with owner’s costs identified separately.
  • Operations and maintenance: Fixed costs, generally expressed per kilowatt-year, and variable non-fuel costs, generally expressed per megawatt-hour.
  • Implementation: Indicative schedules from contractor notice to proceed through commercial operation, plus representative project cash flows.
  • Dispatch inputs: Parameters such as capacity factors, startup and shutdown durations, ramp rates, and operating limits.

Together, these inputs help portfolio models compare resources according to how they may be built, operated, and dispatched—not simply how much capacity they offer.

How operating characteristics shape resource roles

Technology labels alone do not determine how a plant fits into a system. Operating flexibility and efficiency influence whether a resource is better suited to peaking, load-following, intermediate, or higher-utilization service.

Thermal generation: flexibility and efficiency trade-offs

Simple-cycle combustion turbines and RICE units were assessed as options for peaking or load-following operation. The assessment describes their rapid response as relevant to those roles. RICE units were characterized as generally smaller than utility-scale combustion turbines and less susceptible to performance changes from ambient temperature and elevation. Dual-fuel configurations were also considered, allowing fuel oil as a backup to natural gas; the dual-fuel RICE configuration had lower output and efficiency than its gas-only counterpart, including when operating on natural gas.

Combined-cycle generation uses a heat recovery steam generator to capture energy in turbine exhaust and produce steam for a steam turbine. This increases thermal efficiency compared with simple-cycle operation, but the assessment characterizes combined cycle as less responsive in starting and ramping. That makes the distinction between flexible operation and fuel efficiency important when selecting dispatch-model assumptions.

Renewables and storage: location and duration matter

Wind and solar performance was represented using estimated net capacity factors developed with National Renewable Energy Laboratory performance software. The study examined different proxy sites, illustrating why renewable resource assumptions depend on location. Its wind cases included sites in Montana and Washington, while the solar case represented a single-axis tracking PV facility in Washington.

Storage options were described by both power capacity and duration. The assessment considered closed-loop PHES configurations with eight hours of storage, and lithium-ion and vanadium-flow battery cases with different storage durations and two discharge cycles per day. These distinctions matter to modeling: a megawatt rating alone does not describe how long a storage resource can discharge or the cycling assumptions used to estimate costs.

Interpreting cost estimates and project schedules

The capital estimates used an overnight, turnkey EPC basis in 2018 dollars, excluding escalation. They included conceptual project scope and separately identified owner’s costs, which can cover development, permitting, contracting, and owner’s engineering support. Estimated costs for major electrical and gas interconnections were also presented separately from the facility scope. The study cautioned that its interconnection estimates did not account for electrical or gas network upgrades.

These boundaries are essential when comparing alternatives. A quoted facility cost does not necessarily represent the full cost of connecting a resource or preparing it for operation. Likewise, owner’s costs and construction financing assumptions should not be confused with EPC costs. The assessment included an allowance for funds used during construction allocation in its cost framework, while noting that the opinion of probable owner’s costs did not include AFUDC or interest during construction.

Schedules were conceptual estimates from contractor notice to proceed to commercial operation. They did not include earlier development activities such as feasibility work, permitting, contracting, or regulatory processes. Pumped hydro was treated differently: because of site- and development-specific uncertainty, no implementation schedule was provided, although a duration range was discussed.

Use modeling inputs with appropriate caution

Capacity factors used to estimate annual operating costs are assumptions, not predictions of actual utilization. For dispatchable technologies, utilization depends on the results of dispatch modeling. Renewable production and storage use were estimated using anticipated generation or storage capability and cycling assumptions. A planning model should therefore distinguish between technical capability and the operating pattern assumed for a particular scenario.

Other estimates also have limits. Thermal and biomass emissions were estimated for comparison at steady-state, full-load operation and were explicitly not intended for permitting. Conceptual costs were based on generic inputs, supplier feedback, public information, and previous project experience. The assessment described their accuracy as appropriate for comparative planning, not budget development, and noted that actual project costs can vary with site conditions, labor, materials, contractor methods, and market conditions.

Build a consistent basis for resource decisions

For industrial and utility decision-makers, the practical value of IRP inputs lies in disciplined comparison. Establish consistent assumptions for site conditions, performance, operating costs, interconnection scope, and schedules. Then test how dispatch patterns and utilization affect portfolio results rather than treating planning values as fixed project outcomes.

The 2018 assessment provides a structured example of comparing thermal, renewable, and storage resources across technical and economic dimensions. Its figures are historical, conceptual inputs—not current quotations. The broader takeaway is to use transparent assumptions to identify trade-offs, then refine promising options with project-specific engineering, site evaluation, permitting, and commercial proposals before making investment decisions.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author