Integrated resource planning is a way to evaluate electricity supply, demand-side measures and reliability needs as parts of one long-term system. Moreno Valley Utility’s (MVU) 2018 plan applied that approach across a 20-year horizon, balancing affordable service with renewable procurement, greenhouse gas reduction goals and dependable capacity. For industrial energy users and technical decision-makers, its central lesson is that resource choices depend on more than annual energy consumption: load shape, timing, flexibility and uncertainty matter too.
Why integrated resource planning looks beyond supply
MVU developed its plan voluntarily, using California’s policy framework and guidance for publicly owned utilities. The objective was to identify a diverse portfolio that could meet future electricity needs while maintaining reliability and managing costs. That requires examining both supply-side resources—such as renewable generation and conventional capacity—and measures that affect demand, including energy efficiency, demand response, rooftop solar and electric vehicle charging.
The plan treated energy efficiency as a continuing part of the resource mix. It assumed existing programs and an additional achievable savings target of 0.65% of retail electric sales annually, consistent with a City Council policy. Efficiency and demand response can change the amount of energy the utility must procure, as well as peak demand. They therefore belong in the load forecast and resource comparison, rather than being considered separately from supply planning.
Scenarios make uncertainty visible
Long-term forecasts are not guarantees. Economic growth, customer decisions and technology adoption can all cause actual demand to differ from projections. MVU addressed this uncertainty through scenarios, portfolios and sensitivities. Scenarios represented different policy and emissions assumptions; portfolios combined resources in different ways; and sensitivities tested how results might change when individual assumptions varied.
Three scenarios spanned a range of renewable and clean-energy ambitions. The base case reflected a 50% renewable portfolio standard (RPS) target by 2030, with a 5% procurement margin in each compliance period. A more ambitious case modeled a 60% RPS by 2030 and 100% non-carbon-emitting resources by 2045. A stretch case tested a 75% RPS by 2025 and 100% clean energy by 2035. These were planning cases, not predictions that every policy target would necessarily be adopted.
The analysis also considered low, mid and high load forecasts. Sensitivities included different levels of efficiency and behind-the-meter solar, flexible electric vehicle charging, changes in solar and battery costs, and lower demand growth. This structure helps planners distinguish decisions that perform acceptably across conditions from those that depend heavily on a single forecast.
Load shape affects renewable integration
MVU’s forecast combined historical energy use and peak demand with projected growth. It also accounted for demand-side modifiers: electric vehicles, behind-the-meter photovoltaic systems and energy efficiency. Seasonal, monthly, daily and hourly load profiles were used to represent when electricity is needed—not just how much is used over a year.
That timing becomes especially important as solar generation grows. The plan describes the “duck curve”: net demand falls during sunny midday hours, when solar output is high, then rises as solar production declines toward the evening peak. The resulting pattern can reduce the value of some daytime energy while increasing the need for flexible resources that can respond to evening ramps. It can also increase the possibility of renewable curtailment during periods when supply exceeds system needs.
For industrial facilities, these system-level changes provide context for evaluating operating schedules, electrification and participation in demand-response programs. The plan specifically identifies electric vehicle charging rates as a potential way to encourage charging when power costs are lower and to better align new load with the utility’s system profile. The broader planning point is to consider when flexible demand can operate, not only its total energy requirement.
Storage, capacity and procurement risk
Energy storage was considered primarily as a potential capacity and load-shaping resource. In MVU’s modeled portfolios, storage and/or demand response began at 1 MW, with subsequent capacity additions linked to expected solar additions. The plan presents storage as a possible means of shifting energy and supporting resource adequacy, while recognizing that the economics depend on whether costs and system-wide benefits accrue to the same parties.
Reliability planning also included a capacity reserve margin of at least 15% above expected annual and monthly peak demand. Separately, MVU included a 5% renewable procurement margin to manage exposure to load variation, renewable performance and possible contract failure. These provisions address different risks: one supports capacity adequacy, while the other provides a buffer for meeting renewable procurement requirements.
Procurement timing is another challenge. Utilities may need to secure resources through multiyear contracts, while customer demand can change without comparable long-term commitments. Buying too little can threaten supply adequacy; buying too much can leave customers carrying the cost of excess or stranded resources. Scenario analysis and a diversified portfolio are ways to manage that tension, though they cannot eliminate uncertainty.
What MVU selected—and why it matters
MVU identified Case B2 as its preferred portfolio. It paired the more progressive policy scenario with a portfolio that included storage and/or demand response, and a renewable mix modeled as 70% solar and 30% wind for the RPS net short. The plan positioned this case to pursue MVU’s share of statewide emissions reductions while preparing for higher renewable requirements. Case A1 remained the minimum-procurement base case, while the still more ambitious Case C3 was treated as a stretch goal rather than the recommended choice.
The preferred portfolio was not simply the case with the lowest modeled cost in every load condition. The plan compared costs across low, mid and high demand forecasts and weighed policy alignment and resource characteristics alongside cost. Its reported mid-demand net present value for new resource acquisition over the 20-year planning horizon was approximately $297.7 million. That figure is specific to the plan’s assumptions and analysis; it should not be treated as a general cost benchmark.
Practical implications for energy decision-makers
MVU’s 2018 plan illustrates a disciplined planning sequence: forecast energy and peak demand, represent changing load shapes, test alternative policy futures, compare resource combinations, and assess reliability and cost together. For industrial organizations, system integrators and plant leaders, the same framework reinforces the value of understanding how facility loads interact with utility peak periods, renewable availability and changing procurement conditions.
The practical takeaway is to treat electricity planning as an ongoing process rather than a one-time capacity decision. Demand forecasts, efficiency, flexible loads, storage and supply contracts all affect the outcome, and their relative value can shift as policy and market conditions change. MVU’s plan explicitly recognized that its assumptions could evolve and called for periodic updates—an important principle for any organization making long-lived energy and infrastructure decisions.