An investment performance review needs to look beyond a single quarter’s returns. The March 31, 2019 review of Washoe County’s 457 and 401(a) plans illustrates why: markets rebounded sharply after late-2018 weakness, but several actively managed funds continued to lag their benchmarks over longer periods. For plan administrators and investment decision-makers, the report connects market conditions, portfolio allocations and manager oversight in one assessment.
Q1 2019 market performance: a broad rebound
Equity markets advanced strongly during the first quarter of 2019. US stocks led international markets, with the S&P 500 returning 13.6% and the Russell 2000 gaining 14.6%. The Russell MidCap Index rose 16.5%. Returns were positive across US market capitalizations and styles, while growth indices generally outperformed value indices.
Investors responded to several developments: the Federal Reserve adopted a more accommodative posture, US-China trade negotiations appeared to progress, and the partial US government shutdown ended. These factors helped outweigh concerns about slowing global growth and mixed economic data. Cyclical sectors, including information technology, industrials and energy, were among the stronger large-cap performers. Lower interest rates also supported real estate investment trusts.
International equities also gained. The MSCI ACWI ex USA Index returned 10.3% in US dollars, while the MSCI EAFE and Emerging Markets indices returned 10.0% and 9.9%, respectively. Currency movements mattered: over the trailing year, the ACWI ex USA Index was up 1.9% in local-currency terms but down 4.2% for US-dollar investors.
Fixed income gains and an inverted yield curve
Bond returns were positive but more modest than equity returns. The Bloomberg Barclays US Aggregate Index gained 2.9% during the quarter. A shift in Federal Reserve guidance toward a pause in rate increases contributed to falling Treasury yields across maturities. Rates declined most in the middle and longer portions of the curve, leaving short-term yields above some longer-term yields.
Investment-grade corporate bonds returned 5.1%, outperforming Treasury and mortgage-backed securities. The report attributes this in part to their greater interest-rate sensitivity, higher yields and tighter credit spreads. High-yield bonds also performed strongly, gaining 7.3% as spreads narrowed. The review notes that an inverted yield curve has historically preceded recessions, but presents this as a market signal rather than a certainty about future conditions.
Plan asset allocation at quarter-end
The 457 plan held approximately $164.7 million at March 31, while the 401(a) plan held about $12.2 million. Cash was the largest reported allocation in both plans: 44.8% of the 457 plan and 35.4% of the 401(a) plan, primarily represented by the MassMutual Guaranteed Interest Account. US equity accounted for 41.7% of the 457 plan and 47.6% of the 401(a) plan.
The remaining allocations spanned US fixed income, balanced funds, international equities and international fixed income. Retirement model portfolios were also included. Reviewing allocation by both asset class and manager helps decision-makers see how the overall portfolio is distributed and how individual investment options contribute to that mix. These figures are a snapshot at quarter-end, not a forecast or recommendation.
Fund oversight: separating short-term recovery from longer-term results
The plan’s evaluation framework considers returns, risk, portfolio characteristics, style consistency and manager tenure. Performance is assessed across multiple time horizons and against both benchmarks and peer groups. The report describes three overall statuses: Pass (Satisfactory), Guarded and Watch. A breach of one or more criteria does not automatically require remedial action; the findings inform continued review.
Two funds were placed on Watch. Lazard Emerging Markets Equity was downgraded because of continued weak relative performance against peers and its market index. The review identified the fund’s value style as a principal contributor to its one-, three- and five-year underperformance. DFA International Small Cap Value was also placed on Watch after significant underperformance over the prior year weakened its longer-term relative results.
Hotchkis & Wiley Mid Cap Value remained Guarded. Although it improved during the quarter, its three- and five-year returns continued to lag its benchmark. Its ten-year annualized relative results were stronger, and the report noted that value-style weakness had weighed on performance. The stated response for these funds was continued monitoring.
Practical implications for plan decision-makers
The review demonstrates why a strong quarter should not replace a disciplined assessment of longer-term performance and portfolio fit. Market context can help explain returns, while comparisons with benchmarks and peers can identify where further scrutiny is appropriate. At the same time, allocation data provides a separate view of how much exposure each plan has to cash, equities and fixed income.
For investment committees and plan administrators, the practical takeaway is to maintain a consistent evaluation process: assess several time horizons, consider risk and style alongside returns, and distinguish a monitoring flag from an automatic decision to remove a fund. In this review, markets recovered broadly, but fund-level concerns remained visible—making ongoing oversight central to understanding the plans’ investment position.