Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

For companies developing technologies with potential defense applications, understanding the MDA SBIR proposal requirements is essential before preparing a submission. The Missile Defense Agency’s 20.2 Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) instructions describe how firms were expected to demonstrate technical feasibility, meet eligibility rules and submit a complete Phase I package. The announcement is historical, but its requirements illustrate the range of compliance and proposal-planning issues addressed in an agency-specific SBIR solicitation.

Start with eligibility and announcement rules

The instructions direct offerors to read both the Department of Defense announcement and MDA-specific guidance. Proposals that did not conform to the announcement’s terms would not be considered. MDA also reserved the right to limit awards and fund only proposals it judged to have superior scientific and technical quality.

Each offeror had to qualify as a small business at the time of award under the referenced Small Business Administration regulations and certify its status in the proposal cover sheet. Applicants also needed to register in the SBA Company Registry before submission and use the resulting control ID. Firms that did not meet the applicable Phase I performance benchmarks were ineligible under the stated rules.

Eligibility checks extended beyond size status. MDA could request corporate records before award to assess ownership eligibility. Requested documents could include articles of incorporation, bylaws or operating agreements, voting stock certificates, board minutes, and lists of officers and board members. The instructions warned that failure to provide requested documentation in a timely manner could affect eligibility.

Build the Phase I package around the required volumes

The MDA Phase I submission used the Defense SBIR/STTR Innovation Portal (DSIP). The required package contained five volumes, with a sixth optional volume for supporting documents:

  • Volume 1: Proposal cover sheet.
  • Volume 2: Technical volume, limited to 15 pages.
  • Volume 3: Cost volume, submitted using the required online form.
  • Volume 4: Company Commercialization Report, required even if the firm had no previous SBIR/STTR awards.
  • Volume 5: Optional letters of support and/or a Technical and Business Assistance (TABA) request.
  • Volume 6: Fraud, Waste, and Abuse training certification.

The 15-page limit applied to the technical volume. Material placed in other volumes would not be evaluated as a substitute for technical content that belonged in Volume 2, and pages beyond the limit would not be evaluated. The cover sheet, cost volume and commercialization report did not count toward that limit. MDA accepted only letters of support and TABA requests in Volume 5; other supporting documentation placed there would not be considered.

Make the technical case within the page limit

MDA described the purpose of Phase I as determining the merit and technical feasibility of a proposed concept. The Phase I contract period was six months, with an award ceiling of $150,000, or $155,000 when TABA was included, as stated in the checklist. A strong technical volume therefore needed to explain the proposed approach and the work that would establish feasibility, rather than rely on material outside the designated volume.

Reviewers were not assumed to know the offeror, its personnel or any experiments cited. Relevant supporting information, including publications and government reports, needed to be included in the proposal and counted toward the applicable page limit. The instructions also cautioned against describing hardware, software or technical data as formal government “deliverables”; they supplied alternative language for items intended for government testing, evaluation or demonstration.

Address security, export controls and conflicts of interest

The announcement required disclosure of foreign nationals, green-card holders and dual citizens expected to participate, regardless of whether a topic was identified as export controlled. For each person, offerors were to provide country of origin, visa or work permit type, and anticipated project involvement. MDA could conduct security reviews, and participation could be restricted if a person was found ineligible to perform the proposed work.

Many topics were subject to International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR), Export Administration Regulations (EAR), or both. Firms were responsible for complying with applicable export controls, and a Technology Control Plan could be requested during negotiations for relevant topics. Classified proposals were not accepted; including classified information in an unclassified submission could make it non-responsive.

Offerors also had to consider organizational conflicts of interest under Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) 9.5. A potential conflict could arise if a firm or employee helped develop an SBIR requirement or topic. The instructions noted that an acceptable mitigation plan might be required before award. Prime contractors also needed to account for applicable clauses flowing down to subcontractors, including public-release and covered-information requirements.

Understand how proposals were evaluated

Phase I proposals were assessed using criteria in descending order of importance: the soundness, technical merit and innovation of the approach; the qualifications of the principal investigators, staff and consultants; and the potential for commercial application and expected commercialization benefits. Potential benefit to the Ballistic Missile Defense System was considered across the evaluation and in the best-value decision. The stated criteria collectively carried significantly more weight than cost or price.

Letters of support were optional, but a qualified letter could inform the commercialization criterion. The instructions described such a letter as coming from a relevant commercial or government procuring organization, explaining the technology’s relevance and potential importance, and possibly indicating future funding or program insertion interest. It had to be submitted in the designated Volume 5 category to be considered.

Plan for compliance as well as technical merit

The MDA SBIR 20.2 instructions show that a Phase I proposal required coordinated technical, business and compliance planning. Firms needed to verify eligibility, follow the volume structure and page limit, disclose personnel and export-control considerations, and ensure that every required certification was complete. They also had to present a self-contained technical case that addressed feasibility and the evaluation criteria.

For organizations reviewing historical solicitations or preparing for future opportunities, the practical lesson is to treat the agency-specific instructions as part of the proposal strategy—not as administrative details to resolve at the end. Always check the current announcement for updated dates, limits, forms and policy requirements before submitting.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author