Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

For industrial automation systems, the reliability of controllers, interface electronics and other digital circuitry depends partly on how their components withstand aging and electrical disturbances. At the device level, negative bias temperature instability (NBTI) can degrade PMOS transistors over time, while radiation-induced events can create transient glitches in logic circuits. A study of an NBTI-tolerant Schmitt trigger examines how circuit architecture affects both concerns, comparing a conventional CMOS inverter and Schmitt trigger with an NMOS-only Schmitt trigger that uses a voltage booster (NST-VB).

The results are based on HSPICE simulations using a 32 nm CMOS technology model. They point to a design-level trade-off worth considering: a circuit topology intended to reduce NBTI effects may also improve resistance to modeled soft errors, but its power and implementation characteristics must be assessed as part of the design.

Why aging and soft errors matter to logic circuits

BTI is a time-dependent degradation mechanism. NBTI primarily affects PMOS transistors and can increase their threshold voltage, reducing transistor performance. As devices age, the resulting changes can affect circuit delay and noise margins. Higher operating temperatures can accelerate the degradation. In a digital system, these changes can contribute to timing problems or make a circuit more sensitive to disturbances.

Soft errors have a different origin. A particle strike can deposit charge at a sensitive circuit node and create a temporary voltage pulse, known as a single-event transient (SET). In combinational logic, a glitch may propagate through downstream gates and cause an incorrect result. In storage elements, a related event can upset the stored state. Lower supply voltages and smaller node capacitances can increase susceptibility by reducing the charge required to disturb a node.

That minimum disturbance is described by critical charge, or Qcrit. A higher critical charge generally indicates that a larger charge disturbance is needed to cause a logic error, making it a useful indicator of soft-error resilience. Aging can reduce Qcrit, so evaluating soft-error behavior without accounting for device stress may not capture the circuit’s performance over time.

How the NBTI-tolerant Schmitt trigger is designed

A conventional Schmitt trigger uses hysteresis: its switching threshold depends on whether the input is rising or falling. This helps reject input variations that do not cross the relevant threshold, improving noise immunity compared with a standard inverter. However, the design assessed in the study uses multiple PMOS transistors in its pull-up network, making it susceptible to NBTI degradation.

The NST-VB combines Schmitt-trigger feedback with an NMOS-only critical path and a voltage booster. Using NMOS transistors in the path that drives the output is intended to reduce the impact of NBTI on key circuit characteristics. Feedback in the pull-down network establishes different switching thresholds and supports noise margin. The voltage booster addresses limitations associated with a basic NMOS inverter, including restricted output swing and a direct-current path in certain operating conditions. The design therefore makes a trade-off: the booster can increase leakage power dissipation.

The voltage booster is supplied at a higher voltage than the main circuit in the modeled design. That detail is important when interpreting the results: the NST-VB is not simply a drop-in inverter with no additional considerations. Its power, supply requirements and integration into a larger design need to be considered alongside its reliability benefits.

What the simulations indicate about soft-error resilience

The researchers compared the three circuit types under different supply voltages and stress times. Their method used a chain of three inverters, placing the circuit under test between a driver and a load. A double-exponential current pulse represented charge deposited by a particle strike. The simulated critical charge was the minimum injected charge needed to produce the specified logic-changing behavior.

In the reported simulations, the NST-VB had a higher critical charge than the CMOS inverter and conventional Schmitt-trigger inverter. After three years of modeled stress, its critical-charge sensitivity was reported as improved by 62.48% compared with the CMOS inverter and 55.10% compared with the Schmitt-trigger counterpart. The study also introduced a soft-error rate ratio (SERR) to compare behavior before and after stress. Under the reported conditions, the NST-VB showed 12.62% and 12.39% less SERR than the Schmitt-trigger and CMOS alternatives, respectively.

The topology also mattered in the analysis of particle strikes at internal nodes. Feedback helped recover some simulated glitches before they could flip the output. In the NST-VB, the authors identified the input node as the critical location for further comparison; other internal-node disturbances did not produce the same logic-flipping behavior in the modeled cases.

Aging, process variation and implementation trade-offs

The simulations found a smaller delay shift for the NST-VB after three years of stress than for the other circuits: 0.47%, compared with 7.2% for the conventional Schmitt trigger and 5.32% for the CMOS inverter. The authors attribute the Schmitt trigger’s greater NBTI impact in part to its pull-up network containing three PMOS transistors, versus one in the CMOS inverter. These values describe the study’s modeled conditions, including its selected technology, supply voltages, temperature and stress assumptions; they should not be treated as universal component-level guarantees.

Process variation was assessed using 5,000 Monte Carlo simulations of critical input and output voltages. The study reports lower variability for the NST-VB than for the CMOS and Schmitt-trigger designs. This suggests that the topology may be less sensitive to modeled process differences, although verification in the target process and operating environment remains necessary.

There are practical costs. The NST-VB had higher static power than the two comparison circuits in the reported analysis, while its dynamic power was lower than that of the conventional Schmitt trigger. Its area was also lower than the Schmitt trigger’s in the study, though higher than the CMOS inverter’s. These results reinforce the need to assess reliability alongside power and area rather than optimizing one measure in isolation.

Practical implications for automation electronics

For engineers designing digital circuitry used in industrial control and automation, the study highlights the value of considering aging and transient disturbances together. A circuit with hysteresis can improve noise immunity, but its transistor composition may influence long-term NBTI sensitivity. An NMOS-only critical path with feedback and voltage boosting offers a potential alternative when soft-error resilience and aging behavior are priorities.

The findings are simulation-based, so design teams should validate the approach against the target fabrication process, supply conditions, thermal profile and power budget. The practical takeaway is not that one topology suits every application, but that circuit-level choices can affect critical charge, delay degradation and process-variation sensitivity. Evaluating those measures together can help guide more reliable logic design.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author