Understanding the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) is essential to improving water electrolysis, because converting water into oxygen involves multiple proton- and electron-transfer steps and formation of an O–O bond. Oxygen isotope effects provide a way to probe which step controls the reaction rate. Directly measuring isotope ratios in oxygen produced at solid electrodes can connect catalyst behavior with the underlying reaction mechanism.
A study using isotope ratio mass spectrometry (IRMS) demonstrated this approach on nanoporous iron oxide and iridium electrodes. Its results show that measured isotope effects depend on both electrode material and applied overpotential. For iron oxide, the evidence points to O–O bond formation through water attack on a high-valent iron–oxo intermediate, rather than formation of that intermediate being the rate-determining step.
Why identify the rate-determining step in water oxidation?
Water splitting consists of two half-reactions: oxidation of water to dioxygen and reduction of protons to dihydrogen. The oxygen evolution reaction is kinetically demanding because it requires four electrons and four protons, as well as the creation of an oxygen–oxygen bond. Its overpotential therefore makes a major contribution to the additional energy needed to drive electrolysis beyond the thermodynamic potential.
Many types of materials have been explored as OER catalysts, including noble-metal oxides and oxides or oxyhydroxides of more abundant transition metals. Designing better catalysts requires more than comparing current or activity: researchers also need to know which elementary step limits turnover. That step may vary with the electrode, electrolyte, pH, temperature and applied potential.
For iron oxide, prior mechanistic work supported an initial oxidation of a hydroxylated iron surface to a high-valent iron(IV)-oxo species, often called a ferryl intermediate. The subsequent chemistry remained less settled. Competing possibilities included a later oxidation or deprotonation step, and alternative ways to form the O–O bond.
How oxygen isotope effects reveal reaction steps
A kinetic isotope effect (KIE) arises when replacing an atom with a heavier isotope changes a reaction rate. The difference is most informative when a bond involving that atom is made or broken in, or before, the rate-controlling part of the reaction. For OER, comparing oxygen-18 and oxygen-16 is especially relevant because oxygen atoms are involved directly in O–O bond formation.
Earlier isotope-effect studies were limited for heterogeneous electrode systems, in part because isotope labeling can be difficult and the small changes in natural isotope abundance require precise measurement. The reported approach analyzed dissolved oxygen produced during electrolysis at its natural abundance. IRMS measured the oxygen isotope composition directly, without first converting the oxygen to carbon dioxide.
The experiments used steady-state electrolysis with nanoporous Fe2O3 in neutral phosphate buffer and iridium in acidic sulfuric acid. Oxygen dissolved in the electrolyte was collected in small, sealed samples for isotope analysis. The researchers varied the applied overpotential and calculated oxygen-18 KIE values from the measured isotope ratios.
Overpotential changes isotope selectivity
For both electrode materials, the oxygen product was relatively enriched in oxygen-18 compared with the water at lower overpotentials. As overpotential increased, the product’s isotope composition moved closer to that of the water, and the measured KIE approached unity. A KIE near one indicates little observed discrimination between the two oxygen isotopes under those conditions.
This trend does not, by itself, require the catalyst to switch mechanisms. Overpotential changes the activation barriers for electrochemical reactions. When the driving force increases, the difference in isotope-sensitive activation barriers can become less consequential. At sufficiently high turnover, transport of reactants can also limit the observed process, reducing the isotope selectivity expressed in the product.
The change occurred at different overpotential ranges for the two materials. Iridium approached a KIE of one at lower overpotential than iron oxide, consistent with the different catalytic behavior observed in the experiments. The important practical point is that isotope effects should be interpreted alongside operating potential and electrode material, rather than treated as a fixed signature independent of conditions.
What the isotope results indicate for iron oxide
At lower overpotentials, Fe2O3 showed inverse oxygen-18 KIE values: the measured ratio was below one. The researchers considered whether the rate-determining step was oxidation and deprotonation to produce the ferryl intermediate, or whether it was the subsequent O–O bond-forming step.
The first explanation did not fit the combined isotope evidence. Accounting for the expected isotope effect associated with water binding would require an oxidation-step KIE inconsistent with values reported for related iron systems. It also conflicted with the inverse deuterium isotope effect measured for the iron oxide electrode. Together, these comparisons argue against ferryl formation as the rate-determining step.
Instead, the oxygen-18 and deuterium results are consistent with O–O bond formation being rate-limiting. Within that interpretation, the estimated isotope effect favors an acid–base pathway: water attacks the surface ferryl species to form the O–O bond. The results therefore support nucleophilic water attack over direct coupling between neighboring metal–oxo units. This is a mechanistic conclusion for the tested iron oxide system and conditions, not a universal rule for all OER catalysts.
Implications for catalyst development
Direct natural-abundance isotope analysis offers a way to investigate heterogeneous electrocatalysts without relying solely on indirect measurements of intermediates or reaction kinetics. Used with electrochemical data and other mechanistic tools, isotope effects can help distinguish whether a catalyst is limited by formation of a reactive metal–oxo species or by the chemistry that follows it.
For catalyst research and process development, the findings highlight several considerations:
- Evaluate operating potential: isotope discrimination changes with overpotential, so measurements at a single condition may not describe behavior across an operating range.
- Compare catalyst materials carefully: iron oxide and iridium displayed different potential-dependent isotope profiles.
- Use complementary evidence: oxygen-18 effects, deuterium effects and intermediate-sensitive studies can strengthen or challenge a proposed mechanism.
- Distinguish mechanistic insight from performance claims: identifying a rate-limiting step can guide catalyst design, but it does not by itself establish practical efficiency or operating lifetime.
Conclusion
Oxygen isotope effects measured directly in evolved oxygen can provide mechanistic information about water oxidation at solid electrode surfaces. In the reported experiments, the isotope response depended on both applied overpotential and electrode composition. For nanoporous iron oxide, the evidence disfavors ferryl formation as the rate-determining step and instead supports rate-limiting O–O bond formation through water attack on the ferryl intermediate. For engineers and catalyst developers, the broader implication is that understanding the controlling reaction step—and how it shifts with operating conditions—can help focus the search for improved water-oxidation materials.