Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

For industrial automation companies, patent disputes can affect product development, technology partnerships and the commercial risks surrounding connected equipment and control systems. The patent litigation trends in 2015 showed a legal landscape in motion: more proceedings were filed, PTAB activity continued to expand, and district court determinations shifted toward invalidity rather than infringement.

The year’s figures also show why case counts alone provide an incomplete picture. The number of proceedings, parties, patent accusations and court decisions each measures a different aspect of litigation activity. Together, they offer a more useful view for technical decision-makers working with patent portfolios, licensed technology or products that may face infringement claims.

Patent litigation trends in 2015: more cases, fewer district court accusations

New patent litigation proceedings across U.S. district courts, the International Trade Commission (ITC) and the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) rose 13% in 2015, reaching 7,597. District court cases increased 15%, while new PTAB proceedings rose 7%. The number of litigants in new proceedings also grew, by 12.6% overall.

However, the number of patent accusations asserted in new cases increased by only 1.3%. In district courts, accusations fell 5.5%, reaching their lowest level since 2009. PTAB accusations moved in the opposite direction, rising 64% in 2015. This divergence suggests that a growing case count did not mean every forum was seeing a comparable increase in the number of patent issues being challenged.

Other measures underline the difference between activity and workload. Total docket entries declined for the first time since 2008, falling about 2.4% overall. District court docket entries dropped around 10%, while PTAB entries increased 23%. Claim constructions—the process of interpreting disputed patent claim language—rose 18% across proceedings, including a 10% increase in district courts and a 34% increase at the PTAB.

PTAB proceedings matured, but final decisions remained consequential

The PTAB’s review process continued to develop in 2015. At the institution stage, the balance between claims instituted for review and claims not instituted became more even overall, but the pattern varied by the legal grounds asserted. Net institutions declined for challenges based on anticipation under 35 U.S.C. § 102 and on § 112. Obviousness challenges under § 103 remained relatively flat in the first half of the year, then rose sharply in the second half.

Institution patterns for challenges under § 101 also shifted. After rising through 2014, net institutions for unpatentable subject matter began declining in April 2015. These changes matter because institution is an early decision about whether a PTAB review proceeds; it is not the final determination on patentability.

Among PTAB proceedings that reached a final written decision, 78.8% resulted in one or more claims being found unpatentable. For organizations assessing exposure, the distinction between institution and final decision is important: early-stage review outcomes and final determinations describe different points in the process.

Section 101 challenges gained influence, with outcomes varying by court

Following the 2014 Alice decision, challenges to patent eligibility under 35 U.S.C. § 101 became a significant part of district court litigation. From the decision through the end of 2015, district courts addressed 191 such challenges. Sixty-seven percent were granted in whole or in part, meaning the ruling favored challengers at least partially.

Results differed substantially by district. In the Eastern District of Texas (EDTX), 35% of Section 101 challenges were resolved favorably or partly favorably to challengers. In Delaware, the comparable share was 88%. The report also found that, within a given court, outcomes were similar whether a challenge was brought early or at a more mature stage of litigation.

For patent and engineering teams, the practical point is not that one filing strategy guarantees a result. Rather, the data show that legal outcomes depended on the forum and the specific proceeding, making jurisdiction and case context important considerations in risk planning.

District court determinations shifted against patentees

Although the total number of district court patent determinations fell almost 16% from 2014, 2015 still had the second-highest annual total since 2008. The mix of decisions changed sharply: invalidity determinations increased by more than 53%, while infringement determinations declined by nearly 47%.

As a share of all patent determinations, invalidity reached 27.1% in 2015, compared with 14.9% in 2014. Infringement determinations fell to 14.4%, the lowest proportion in the period covered. The report also found that more than 70% of bench-trial determinations favored patentees, while 67.5% of summary judgment determinations favored accused infringers or patent challengers. Outcomes therefore varied not only by court, but also by the type of proceeding.

Why case volume needs context

The Eastern District of Texas remained the leading venue by number of new cases, accounting for 44.2% of the total. Yet its share was 27.9% of litigants and 19.4% of accusations. Delaware, by comparison, accounted for 22.5% of new accusations. These differences illustrate how venue rankings change when measured by cases, parties or patent issues rather than by a single headline count.

The report also cautions that case totals can be affected by related proceedings, including venue transfers and consolidations, as well as changes to joinder practices. For companies evaluating litigation exposure, a useful review should therefore consider the number of parties and accusations alongside raw case volume.

Practical implications for industrial technology organizations

The 2015 data point to a patent environment in which more proceedings coexisted with fewer district court accusations, expanding PTAB activity and changing patterns in court determinations. Industrial automation businesses can use these distinctions to make internal reviews more focused:

  • Track more than case counts. Consider parties, accusations, forum and related proceedings when assessing litigation activity.
  • Separate PTAB stages. Institution decisions and final written decisions reflect different outcomes in the review process.
  • Account for jurisdictional variation. Section 101 results differed considerably between districts, and trial and motion outcomes varied by proceeding type.
  • Revisit assumptions over time. Year-to-year changes in invalidity, infringement and review activity can alter the context for patent-risk decisions.

For technical and business leaders, the central lesson is to treat patent litigation metrics as complementary rather than interchangeable. In 2015, rising case volume did not mean a uniform increase in accusations or a consistent pattern of outcomes. A practical view of patent risk depends on understanding the forum, the stage of review and the type of decision—not simply counting lawsuits.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author