Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Reliable PFC emission factors are essential for accounting for greenhouse gases from industrial rare earth metal electrolysis. The process can release perfluorocarbons (PFCs), including CF4 and C2F6, but the 2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories do not provide a dedicated method for estimating emissions from rare earth metal production. Industrial measurements across several production lines help establish a more practical evidence base for inventories and process improvement.

Why PFC emissions matter in rare earth production

Rare earth metals are produced for applications including permanent magnets and high-performance electronic devices. Since the 1990s, molten fluoride-salt electrolysis has become the dominant production route. Like primary aluminium electrolysis, this process uses graphite anodes and fluoride electrolytes, and can generate PFC gases during operation.

CF4 (tetrafluoromethane) was the dominant PFC in the monitored exhaust, accounting for roughly 90% of detected PFCs by mass. C2F6 (hexafluoroethane) contributed around 10%, while C3F8 (octafluoropropane) was below 1%. Trace c-C4F8 and C4F10 were also detected. These gases have high global warming potentials, so even relatively small emissions can be significant in a greenhouse gas inventory.

PFC emission factors: what the industrial measurements found

Measurements were conducted at three rare earth companies in China, covering production of Pr-Nd alloy, La metal and Dy-Fe alloy. Researchers combined continuous on-site Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) monitoring with time-integrated exhaust samples analysed off-site using gas chromatography and mass spectrometry. Monitoring periods ranged from 24 to 60 hours, allowing the work to capture changes during normal production and process events.

The resulting emission factors varied by product and facility. Across the measured production lines, CF4 factors ranged from 26.66 to 109.43 grams per tonne of rare earth product (g/t-RE). C2F6 ranged from 0.26 to 10.95 g/t-RE, and C3F8 from 0.03 to 0.27 g/t-RE. When expressed as carbon dioxide equivalents, total PFC emissions ranged from 211.60 to 847.41 kilograms CO2-e per tonne of product.

Dy-Fe production had the highest measured total, at 847.41 kg CO2-e/t-RE. The study’s Dy-Fe measurements came from a single cell, however, which limits how broadly that result can be applied. For the other measured production lines, total PFC factors were below 350 kg CO2-e/t-RE. The results therefore point to meaningful differences between production types, while also highlighting the need to interpret individual factors in light of the measurement setup and operating conditions.

How process conditions influence emissions

Anode effects and emissions outside peak events

PFC emissions are associated with anode effects: events in which graphite anodes become passivated, reducing their ability to carry current and coinciding with increased cell voltage. In the monitored lines, sharp CF4 peaks were associated with these events. Anode effects accounted for an estimated 53% to 91% of CF4 emissions, depending on the production line.

Emissions were not limited to anode effects. The remaining measured CF4 occurred during periods classified as non-anode-effect emissions. This matters for operations teams: monitoring only voltage-related events may not capture the full emissions profile. A complete estimate needs to account for emissions across the operating period, not just visible peaks.

Cell operation, feeding and gas capture

Factors that may contribute to variation include the metal or alloy being produced, cell design, current, voltage, operating conditions and process-control technology. The study observed lower Pr-Nd emissions at one facility than in an earlier measurement at that facility, alongside improvements to oxide feeding. This supports the importance of examining process changes when interpreting emission trends, but the measurements do not isolate the effect of any single change.

Gas collection is another important part of the calculation. Exhaust sampling alone can miss emissions that escape the collection system. The study used sulfur hexafluoride (SF6) as a tracer to estimate collection efficiency; measured efficiencies at the participating facilities were approximately 53% to 58%. Accounting for this captured fraction helps include fugitive emissions in the emission factor rather than treating stack measurements as a complete measure of cell emissions.

Implications for greenhouse gas accounting and plant teams

The findings offer a basis for developing more representative PFC estimates for rare earth electrolysis, but they do not establish a universal factor for every facility or product. For inventory preparation and future measurement programs, several practices are particularly relevant:

  • Identify the production context. Record the metal or alloy, cell type, electrical current and relevant operating conditions alongside each factor.
  • Measure over representative operating periods. Process events and emissions can vary over time, so brief samples may not reflect typical production.
  • Account for gas collection. Estimate collection efficiency and consider whether fugitive emissions require additional measurement.
  • Use complementary measurement methods. Continuous FTIR monitoring can track CF4, while time-integrated laboratory analysis can help quantify other PFCs that are harder to detect on site.
  • Distinguish peaks from ongoing emissions. Anode-effect events are important, but non-anode-effect emissions also contribute to the total.

Comparisons with aluminium electrolysis should also be made carefully. The study found that rare earth PFC emissions were generally of a lower or similar order of magnitude by product mass, except for the measured Dy-Fe line. That comparison does not remove the need for facility-specific factors: differences in product, cell technology and operating conditions can change the result.

Conclusion

Industrial rare earth electrolysis is a source of CF4, C2F6 and C3F8 emissions that should be considered in greenhouse gas accounting. The measured PFC emission factors vary across products and facilities, with anode effects, operating conditions and gas collection all relevant to interpreting the results. For engineers, plant managers and inventory teams, the practical priority is to pair representative monitoring with clear process data and collection-efficiency estimates. This provides a stronger basis for emissions reporting and for identifying where process control and further measurement deserve attention.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author