In radiation-sensitive electronics, a timing fault can affect far more than the clock itself. A phase-locked loop (PLL) that loses synchronization may cause incorrect data capture or disrupt downstream processing. A radiation-hardened PLL design therefore needs to address the components that generate, compare and control the clock—not just the oscillator. One proposed charge-pump PLL combines radiation hardening by design (RHBD) with redundancy to limit the effects of single-event transients.
The design was simulated as a 2.4 GHz frequency synthesizer with a 20 MHz reference input. Its approach is relevant to engineers working on space, satellite and military electronics, where radiation exposure can threaten reliable timing. The same design principles also offer a useful framework for evaluating fault tolerance in other systems where clock integrity is critical.
Why radiation threatens PLL timing
A PLL compares a reference clock with a divided version of its own output. It uses the resulting phase or frequency error to adjust the output until the two signals are aligned. In a charge-pump PLL, a phase-frequency detector (PFD) signals whether the feedback clock leads or lags. The charge pump converts that signal into current, a loop filter turns the current into a control voltage, and the voltage-controlled oscillator (VCO) adjusts its frequency.
Radiation can disturb several points in this control loop. The source distinguishes between total ionizing dose (TID) and single-event effects (SEE). TID accumulates over time and can shift transistor threshold voltages or increase leakage, potentially affecting VCO operation. SEE occurs when an energetic particle causes a transient disturbance or changes a digital logic state. A strike may affect a divider or PFD, or alter the charge-pump or loop-filter voltage. Depending on the disturbance, the result may be a temporary frequency error or a loss of lock.
Such disturbances can increase jitter, change phase, or cause bit flips. In a system that depends on accurate clocking, those effects can lead to false triggering, incorrect data latching or loss of synchronization.
Radiation-hardened PLL design: a layered approach
Radiation hardening can be achieved through specialized manufacturing processes or through circuit and architectural design. RHBD adapts the circuit while using a commercial CMOS process, rather than relying on a dedicated radiation-hardened fabrication process. The proposed PLL applies RHBD measures across several blocks and adds redundancy in the PFD and charge pump.
Redundant phase detection
The PFD uses triple modular redundancy (TMR): three PFD instances feed a majority voter. If one PFD is affected by a transient, the voter selects the output agreed on by the other two. This is intended to prevent a single disturbed detector from directly controlling the rest of the loop. The simulated design also tested the PFD with a 1 mA, 1 ns current pulse at an input and reported that it continued to produce the correct output.
Charge-pump current balancing
A transient in the charge pump can create a mismatch between the currents that charge and discharge the loop filter. That mismatch can shift the control voltage and disturb the VCO frequency. The design uses two charge-pump circuits and a common-mode feedback (CMFB) circuit to reduce the difference between the UP and DN branch currents.
In the reported simulations, the UP and DN currents measured 168.25 µA and 167.7 µA with CMFB. Without CMFB, the corresponding reported currents were 171.43 µA and 204 µA. These results illustrate the role of feedback in reducing current mismatch in this implementation; they do not establish performance for other circuits or radiation conditions.
Oscillator, filter and divider choices
The loop filter is a passive, third-order design. The VCO uses differential ring oscillators, with radiation-hardened inverters in each stage. Its reported tuning range is 1.8 to 2.7 GHz, with a 2.4 GHz center frequency and a sensitivity of 280 MHz/V.
Because the PFD compares signals at the reference frequency, the 2.4 GHz VCO output must be divided before comparison with the 20 MHz reference. The design uses seven divider stages, each based on a D flip-flop that divides its input frequency by two. Together, they provide the feedback signal for the PLL.
What the simulation results show
Cadence simulations reported a 2.4 GHz output from the 20 MHz reference. Without an injected transient, the reported RMS jitter was 8 ps, phase noise was -118.1 dBc/Hz, and settling time was 52 ns. With the specified single-event transient noise applied, the reported RMS jitter was 128.9 ps, phase noise was -94.03 dBc/Hz, and settling time was 159 ns.
The study also injected a transient pulse at 90 nodes to examine period jitter. The minimum and maximum measured values were 41 ps and 59 ps. These are simulation results for the described implementation and test conditions; they should not be treated as measurements from a fabricated device or as evidence of tolerance to every radiation environment.
Practical implications for system designers
The design demonstrates why radiation tolerance is a system-level concern. Hardening only the oscillator, for example, would leave other vulnerable blocks in the feedback loop. Redundancy in phase detection, current balancing in the charge pump, and hardened oscillator stages target different ways a transient can affect loop behavior.
For engineering teams assessing a similar architecture, useful considerations include:
- Identify vulnerable nodes: Review the PFD, charge pump, loop filter, VCO and divider as parts of one timing-control system.
- Match mitigation to failure mode: Redundancy can address a disturbed logic decision, while current feedback can help limit charge-pump mismatch.
- Test transient response: Evaluate jitter, phase noise and settling behavior under clearly defined fault-injection conditions.
- Separate simulation from qualification: Simulated behavior is valuable for design evaluation but does not replace testing under the radiation conditions relevant to the intended application.
Conclusion
A radiation-hardened PLL must preserve the integrity of the full feedback loop, not simply maintain a nominal oscillator frequency. This 2.4 GHz charge-pump design combines TMR, CMFB, hardened differential ring oscillators and a divided feedback path. Its simulations show how layered RHBD techniques can limit the timing effects of an injected transient. For technical decision-makers, the practical lesson is to pair block-level protection with system-level fault testing—and to interpret simulation results within the limits of the tested conditions.