Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Radiation hardening by design (RHBD) can help CMOS frequency synthesizers maintain reliable operation in environments where energetic particles may disturb circuit nodes. For industrial automation engineers and system designers working with electronics for aerospace, nuclear facilities, or other radiation-exposed applications, the key challenge is to identify which circuit blocks are vulnerable and apply mitigation where it is needed.

A study of a 0.18 µm CMOS frequency synthesizer examined single-event transients (SETs) and single-event upsets (SEUs) across its constituent circuits. Its findings point to a practical design principle: radiation response depends on the function and operating frequency of each block. Bias networks and state-holding elements in high-frequency circuits deserve particular attention.

How single-event effects disrupt synthesizers

When a high-energy particle strikes a semiconductor, charge collected at a transistor junction can produce a short-lived current disturbance. In circuit analysis, this event can be represented by a current pulse at a transistor drain. The resulting voltage disturbance may change a signal’s amplitude or phase, and can affect the logic state of a circuit.

An SET is a transient disturbance: the signal may recover after the pulse, but the temporary phase or amplitude change can still interfere with downstream operation. An SEU occurs when a particle changes the stored state of an element such as a flip-flop. In a frequency divider, an incorrect flip-flop state can create a count error and alter the output signal. A phase shift of 180 degrees at a divider output, for example, is equivalent to a state upset that may propagate through the synthesizer.

These effects matter in a phase-locked loop (PLL), where the frequency synthesizer combines an oscillator, dividers, and supporting circuits to generate and control output signals. A disturbance in one block can therefore affect more than the struck transistor.

Radiation hardening by design: Find vulnerable blocks first

The analysis applied modeled current pulses to transistor drains and evaluated output amplitude, phase shift, and recovery time. This circuit-by-circuit approach showed that sensitivity was not uniform across the design.

Low-frequency blocks—the phase-frequency detector, charge pump, and loop filter—were largely unaffected by the modeled pulses. Their operating period was much longer than the pulse widths considered. By contrast, high-frequency blocks, including the voltage-controlled oscillator (VCO), divide-by-two stage (FD2), mixer buffer, CML-to-CMOS converter, and programmable frequency divider, showed greater susceptibility.

The most significant vulnerabilities differed by block:

  • VCO: The biasing network was sensitive, particularly the current-mirror transistor identified as M5.
  • FD2: The divider was highly susceptible to phase shifts that could represent SEUs and propagate to other circuits.
  • CML-to-CMOS converter: Transistor M35 was identified as a particularly vulnerable point in the analyzed design.
  • Mixer buffer: Phase changes from impacts were small, although transient recovery could still be improved.
  • Programmable divider: The modeled impacts produced output-amplitude variations, but did not change the divider’s state.

This distinction helps prevent overengineering: a visible transient does not necessarily mean that a circuit has suffered a state error, and mitigation should reflect the effect that matters to system operation.

Using RC filtering to limit transient disturbances

For the VCO, the design added resistor-capacitor (RC) filtering to the gates of bias transistors M5 and M6. Increasing the time constant at these nodes reduces how quickly a short current disturbance can change the bias voltage. In the reported design, the added resistors were 4.7 kΩ and the capacitor was 1 pF.

Filtering can introduce trade-offs. In this case, resistor thermal noise degraded the VCO’s phase noise relative to the required specification. The design addressed that issue by adding a capacitive divider around the cross-coupled transistors. This reduced the voltage at their drains and increased the available output swing, bringing phase noise back within the stated standard requirement. The combined changes reduced output phase displacement by about 50% and recovery time by approximately 81% in the reported simulations.

RC filtering was also applied to bias circuits in the FD2, mixer buffer, and CML-to-CMOS converter. The reported recovery-time improvements were approximately 32% for the FD2, 77.9% for the mixer buffer, and 78.83% for the converter. These results illustrate why both transient magnitude and recovery behavior should be assessed when evaluating a mitigation technique.

Adding local redundancy to divider storage

Because the FD2 uses master-slave flip-flops to divide the VCO output by two, its stored state is a critical point of vulnerability. The design combined two local hardening approaches: a dual interlocked storage cell (DICE) and a gated feedback cell (GFC).

DICE-style storage changes the connections between the storage cell and pass cell so that a disturbance is less likely to alter the stored value. The GFC approach uses feedback paths with OR-gate behavior to help hold the latch in a stable state if one input is disturbed. The implementation also used RC filtering in the divider’s bias network.

These techniques add circuit complexity and can increase power consumption. In the reported synthesizer, power rose from 18.5 mW to 21.2 mW following the modifications, with the increase attributed to local redundancy. That cost should be considered alongside the consequences of an upset in the target application.

Practical implications for system designers

The study’s results support a targeted RHBD workflow for frequency-generating circuits:

  1. Model particle impacts as transient current pulses at sensitive transistor junctions.
  2. Test each block for amplitude deviation, phase shift, state changes, and recovery time.
  3. Prioritize state-holding and bias nodes where a disturbance can propagate or cause an incorrect divider state.
  4. Apply mitigation selectively, using RC filtering for transient-sensitive bias networks and local redundancy for vulnerable storage elements.
  5. Recheck normal operation after hardening, including phase noise and power consumption.

Radiation hardening by design is therefore not a single circuit fix. It is a process of locating the nodes and functions that turn a particle strike into a system-level error, then balancing mitigation against operating requirements.

Conclusion

In a CMOS frequency synthesizer, high-frequency blocks and state-holding circuits can be more susceptible to single-event effects than low-frequency support circuitry. RC filtering can limit disturbances in bias networks, while local redundancy can protect divider storage from SEUs. By evaluating transient response, state integrity, recovery, phase noise, and power together, design teams can make focused changes that improve radiation robustness without treating every circuit block as equally vulnerable.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author