Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

For electronics operating in space, a radiation-tolerant VCO is important to maintaining dependable clock generation. A single energetic particle can deposit charge in a CMOS device and cause a single-event upset (SEU), temporarily changing a circuit’s logic state. In a voltage-controlled oscillator (VCO) used within a phase-locked loop (PLL), that disturbance can affect oscillation and may disrupt the loop’s locked condition.

Modelling the path from particle strike to circuit-level response helps engineers identify vulnerable nodes and assess mitigation options. Analysis of a current-starved CMOS VCO shows why the ring-oscillator inverters deserve particular attention, and how radiation-hardened-by-design (RHBD) methods compare with triple modular redundancy (TMR).

How a particle strike can cause an SEU

A single-event effect occurs when an ionizing particle interacts with a semiconductor device. The resulting charge may produce a transient current; if the disturbance is sufficient, it can change a device’s logic state. This is an SEU. Radiation exposure can also cause other effects, including total ionizing dose, but the VCO analysis focuses on the transient response associated with a particle strike.

When a heavy ion travels through CMOS material, it can generate electron–hole pairs along its track. The amount of energy deposited per unit distance is described by linear energy transfer (LET). The resulting charge generation and current depend on factors including the incident ion’s energy, its track and angle of incidence, and the material it passes through. Thus, a strike cannot be represented by a single universal current pulse for every device or exposure condition.

In the modelling approach, an inverter’s physical structure is used to estimate the charge-generation response. A current profile derived from the device simulation is then applied to selected VCO nodes to evaluate circuit behaviour during an upset. This links the radiation interaction at device level to the oscillator’s response.

Why ring-oscillator inverters are a key vulnerability

A current-starved VCO uses an odd number of inverter stages connected as a ring. The inverters provide delay, while the current-starving or biasing circuitry controls the available current and therefore influences oscillation frequency. Changing transistor dimensions and operating conditions can be used to meet frequency requirements.

The study’s design analysis describes a seven-stage ring oscillator for a 450 MHz centre frequency. Its simulations indicate that an SEU has a more significant effect on the logic state of the ring-stage inverters than on the current-starving or biasing stage. That distinction matters: a disturbance to an inverter can affect the switching sequence that sustains oscillation, rather than merely changing a control condition.

Because the VCO is part of a PLL, the consequences may extend beyond the oscillator itself. A particle event can produce an erroneous VCO output for a period of time. The output voltage of the charge pump or loop filter may also be affected, potentially causing the PLL to lose lock. The duration and severity of the circuit response depend on the disturbance and the node where it occurs.

Assessing strike conditions and operating frequency

Radiation simulations use LET-related inputs to represent charge generation along a particle track. The analysis reports that strike geometry can influence device degradation: for incidence angles in the 7–14 degree range, a charge funnel can occupy the channel and produce greater degradation. The precise response remains dependent on the particle, its energy, the material, and the device structure.

The reported results also identify operating frequency as a consideration. Higher-frequency VCOs are described as more susceptible to upset, including response to shorter-duration SEU current. For design teams, this makes it important to evaluate the intended operating range alongside the expected radiation environment, rather than treating radiation tolerance as a property of the inverter alone.

Comparing radiation-hardening options

Triple modular redundancy

TMR uses three VCOs and compares their outputs. The output shared by at least two units is selected, on the assumption that a particle strikes only one VCO at a time and the other two remain unaffected. This provides a voting-based way to tolerate an isolated fault, but it carries a substantial power cost. In the described design comparison, the TMR-based approach dissipates 200% more power than the conventional VCO.

Radiation-hardened-by-design logic

RHBD modifies the circuit design to reduce the impact of a transient disturbance. The examined approach uses a radiation-hardened NOT gate intended to lessen the effect of short current changes. The reported power dissipation is almost 60% higher than that of the conventional VCO—less than the TMR approach in this comparison. The analysis also characterizes RHBD as more accurate than TMR, while noting TMR’s dependence on a single-unit strike assumption.

These figures describe the specific designs assessed; they should not be treated as universal overheads for every implementation. Selecting an approach requires balancing upset tolerance, power consumption, circuit accuracy, and the expected radiation conditions.

Design implications for space electronics

For engineers developing PLL-based clock generation in radiation environments, the practical lesson is to assess vulnerability across both the CMOS device and the complete oscillator loop. Device-level current profiles can help identify sensitive VCO nodes, while circuit-level simulation can show whether an upset affects oscillation or PLL lock. Ring-stage inverters merit particular scrutiny, and incidence geometry and operating frequency should be included in the assessment.

Radiation hardening is not a single design choice. TMR offers redundancy but incurs higher power in the evaluated implementation; RHBD seeks to make the logic itself less sensitive to transient current. The appropriate strategy depends on system constraints and the required response to a particle event. By comparing these trade-offs early, design teams can make more informed decisions about radiation-tolerant VCOs and the reliability of the clock systems they support.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author