Retroactive inter partes review became a constitutional issue in a dispute over a patent that had been granted more than a decade before Congress created the procedure. Collabo Innovations argued that applying the America Invents Act (AIA) process to its 1999 patent violated the Fifth Amendment’s Takings and Due Process Clauses. The case illustrates a central concern for patent owners and technology businesses: how changes to the process for challenging patents interact with rights established under earlier law.
How the patent challenge process changed
When Collabo’s U.S. Patent No. 5,952,714 issued in September 1999, the Patent Act provided for ex parte reexamination as an administrative route for revisiting patent claims. A third party could submit prior art and request that the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) reconsider whether claims were patentable. The patent owner did not face the same level of third-party participation found in later proceedings.
Congress introduced inter partes reexamination in 1999, giving third parties greater opportunities to participate in USPTO review. However, that process generally applied to patents issuing from applications filed on or after November 29, 1999. The petition emphasized that the 1999 patent at issue therefore remained subject to ex parte reexamination, rather than inter partes reexamination.
The AIA, enacted in 2011, replaced inter partes reexamination with inter partes review (IPR). Unlike the earlier process, IPR was made applicable to patents issued before, on, or after its effective date. The change meant that older patents, including Collabo’s, could be challenged through a newer, more adjudicatory administrative proceeding.
What makes inter partes review different
IPR is conducted by a panel of the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB). A patent challenger may petition the USPTO to review claims, and the Board can institute the proceeding when the statutory threshold is met: a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail with respect to at least one challenged claim.
The proceeding includes participation by both the patent owner and challenger. They may submit written materials and evidence, seek discovery, and request an oral hearing. The PTAB then issues a decision on patentability, which may be appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.
The petition also pointed to a difference in amendment rights. In conventional examination or reexamination, a patent applicant can have opportunities to revise claims in response to a rejection. In IPR, a patent owner may move to amend challenged claims, but does not have an absolute right to do so. Collabo argued that this procedural shift mattered when applied to patents whose owners had not faced IPR when those patents were granted.
The constitutional questions raised
Collabo’s petition asked whether applying IPR to a pre-AIA patent violated two protections in the Fifth Amendment:
- The Takings Clause: The petition argued that patent rights are property and that retroactively subjecting an older patent to a new process capable of cancelling claims could impair vested property rights.
- The Due Process Clause: Collabo also argued that applying the later-created procedure to an earlier-issued patent raised concerns about fairness and settled expectations.
The argument relied in part on the history of Congress’s choices about effective dates. Ex parte reexamination had been applied to certain existing patents, but inter partes reexamination was limited prospectively. Collabo contended that this history supported the view that patent owners could reasonably expect the rules governing challenges to their patents to matter.
That position must be distinguished from the legal status of patents generally. The Supreme Court had explained in Oil States Energy Services v. Greene’s Energy Group that patents are subject to the provisions of the Patent Act. It also expressly did not decide whether retroactive application of IPR raised a Takings Clause or due-process problem. Collabo’s petition asked the Court to address those questions; it presented the petitioner’s arguments, not a final Supreme Court ruling that retroactive IPR was unconstitutional.
The dispute involving Collabo and Sony
Collabo sued Sony for patent infringement in the District of Delaware in 2015. Sony petitioned for IPR of the patent, and the PTAB instituted review. The district court litigation was stayed while the administrative proceeding continued. The Board ultimately determined that Sony had shown, by a preponderance of the evidence, that several challenged claims were unpatentable.
On appeal, Collabo challenged aspects of the Board’s patentability analysis and argued that applying IPR to the 1999 patent was unconstitutional. The Federal Circuit affirmed the Board’s decision, relying on its earlier decision in Celgene Corp. v. Peter in rejecting the constitutional challenge. Collabo then sought review by the Supreme Court.
Why retroactivity matters to patent stakeholders
For companies managing patent portfolios, the dispute underscores the importance of distinguishing between a patent’s grant date, the law applicable to its examination, and the procedures later available to challenge it. A patent may be subject to administrative review mechanisms that did not exist when it was issued, depending on the statute’s effective-date provisions.
This issue is relevant across the patent ecosystem:
- Patent owners may need to account for post-grant challenges when evaluating the enforceability and commercial value of older claims.
- Technology businesses and potential licensees may consider administrative review as one route for contesting patent claims, alongside district court litigation.
- Legal and IP teams should assess the procedural and constitutional arguments that may arise when a newer review process is applied to an older patent.
- Operations and engineering leaders should recognize that patent disputes can affect product development, sourcing, licensing, and the risk management decisions tied to technology use.
The petition’s broader point was that a patent’s legal environment can change after issuance. Whether those changes are permissible in a particular case depends on the governing statute and constitutional analysis; the petition itself did not resolve that question.
Practical implications
Retroactive inter partes review brings together two competing policy considerations: the use of administrative proceedings to reassess patent claims and the expectations that patent owners form under the law in place when their patents issue. For industrial technology companies, the practical lesson is to treat patent risk as an ongoing issue rather than a question settled at grant. Portfolio reviews should account for available challenge procedures, while business decisions involving patented technology should be informed by the status of relevant claims and any active proceedings.
Collabo’s case brought the constitutional debate into focus, but it should not be read as establishing that all pre-AIA patents are protected from IPR. Instead, it highlights why effective dates, procedural differences, and the scope of patent rights matter to technical and commercial decision-makers navigating the patent system.