SCR-based ESD protection uses a silicon controlled rectifier to provide a discharge path for electrostatic events. The device can carry substantial current, but conventional SCR designs present a trade-off: a high trigger voltage may expose internal circuitry to damaging voltage, while a low holding voltage can increase latch-up concerns. A proposed two-stage SCR-based circuit addresses both issues by combining a lower-voltage trigger mechanism with a structure intended to raise holding voltage and distribute ESD current across additional paths.
Why trigger and holding voltages matter
An ESD protection device must turn on during an electrostatic event and conduct current away from sensitive IC circuitry. Its trigger voltage is the voltage at which the device begins to conduct through its protection mechanism. If this voltage is too high, the protected circuit may be exposed to a level that threatens its gate oxide before the protection device activates.
After an SCR turns on, it can remain conducting as current flows through its regenerative structure. The holding voltage is the voltage associated with maintaining this on-state. If it is too low, the device may remain on under conditions that create a latch-up risk. For ESD design, therefore, reducing the trigger voltage is not enough on its own: the protection structure also needs an appropriate holding voltage for the application.
In a conventional SCR, an increasing anode voltage can cause avalanche breakdown at the reverse-biased junction between the N-well and P-well. The resulting hole current raises the P-well potential and turns on a lateral NPN bipolar transistor. That transistor’s action helps turn on a lateral PNP transistor, establishing the regenerative conduction path that discharges the ESD current. The conventional structure described in the study has a trigger voltage of about 19 V and a holding voltage of about 1 V, illustrating the design challenges the proposed circuit seeks to address.
How the proposed SCR-based ESD protection circuit works
The design combines a first stage intended to lower the trigger voltage with a second stage that provides additional current paths. In the first stage, a grounded-gate NMOS (GGNMOS) element is incorporated so that avalanche breakdown occurs at an N+ diffusion region rather than relying solely on the conventional well-junction breakdown mechanism. The paper relates this approach to the low-trigger-voltage behavior of an LVTSCR structure.
An additional parasitic PNP bipolar transistor is formed through the P-well and an added P+ diffusion region. It operates in parallel with the existing discharge path. According to the design explanation, this parallel path reduces on-resistance and spreads heat across a wider region, with the aim of improving the circuit’s robustness during an ESD event.
The second stage uses interacting lateral NPN and PNP parasitic bipolar transistors. During an ESD pulse, the rising N-well potential and subsequent avalanche breakdown generate electron-hole pairs. The resulting hole current raises the P-well potential, forward-biasing the emitter-base junction of a parasitic NPN transistor. Its conduction helps turn on parasitic PNP transistors, sustaining the discharge path.
The proposed second stage uses four parasitic bipolar transistors in its operation. The paper presents this multi-transistor arrangement as a way to improve current tolerance compared with a conventional SCR. These are design and simulation findings; they should not be interpreted as a substitute for device qualification in a target process and application.
TCAD results and stacked-device comparison
The electrical characteristics were evaluated using Synopsys TCAD simulation. In the reported comparison, the proposed circuit was assessed against a two-stack conventional SCR. The simulated results were:
- Two-stack conventional SCR: 36.21 V trigger voltage and 2.74 V holding voltage.
- Proposed circuit: 17.60 V trigger voltage and 3.64 V holding voltage.
Within this comparison, the proposed design has both a lower trigger voltage and a higher holding voltage. The lower trigger voltage means the simulated protection structure begins conducting at a lower voltage than the two-stack reference. The higher holding voltage indicates a higher voltage is associated with sustaining its on-state, addressing the low-holding-voltage concern identified for conventional SCRs.
The study also examined stacking the proposed circuit for applications requiring different voltage levels. The simulated two-stack version had a trigger voltage of 33.35 V and a holding voltage of 6.94 V. The four-stack version had values of 50.96 V and 10.51 V, respectively. For comparison, conventional SCR stacks were reported at 36.21 V and 2.74 V for two stacks, 72.32 V and 5.49 V for four stacks, and 110.02 V and 8.38 V for six stacks.
These values show how stacking changes both trigger and holding voltages in the simulated structures. They are specific to the reported circuit designs and simulation conditions, not universal ratings for SCR-based protection devices. The appropriate stack configuration depends on the voltage window the protection scheme must meet.
Design implications for IC protection
For engineers evaluating an ESD clamp, the key takeaway is to consider trigger and holding behavior together. A device that triggers early may help limit exposure of sensitive circuitry, but its post-trigger behavior also matters for latch-up risk. Conversely, increasing holding voltage without considering the application’s voltage requirements may not produce a suitable protection window.
The proposed circuit offers a design approach: use a GGNMOS-related mechanism to lower the trigger voltage, add a parallel PNP path to support current conduction, and use a multi-transistor second stage to contribute to the holding-voltage and current-tolerance objectives. Stacking provides a further way to tailor the simulated voltage characteristics for specific applications.
For practical design decisions, the reported TCAD results are a basis for comparison rather than proof of performance in every IC implementation. Designers must assess the protection window and validate the selected structure in the relevant process and circuit context.
Conclusion
The two-stage SCR-based ESD protection concept targets a central challenge in on-chip protection: triggering at a lower voltage while maintaining a higher holding voltage than a conventional stacked SCR reference. Its TCAD results report 17.60 V trigger and 3.64 V holding voltages for the proposed circuit, with additional stack configurations providing higher voltage values. For industrial and semiconductor design teams, the practical lesson is to evaluate trigger voltage, holding behavior, stacking requirements, and validation needs as a coordinated part of ESD protection design.