Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

In radiation-exposed electronics, a particle strike can generate a brief current pulse that disturbs a sensitive circuit node. That disturbance, known as a single-event transient (SET), may affect signals beyond the point where it originated. Single-event transient mitigation is therefore an important design consideration for engineers working on analog and mixed-signal circuits where stable bias voltages and other critical nodes matter. Enhanced Sensitive Node Active Charge Cancellation (ESNACC) is a radiation-hardening-by-design approach intended to reduce these transients while addressing a drawback of the earlier SNACC technique.

Why single-event transients threaten sensitive nodes

An energetic particle can create electron-hole pairs as it passes through semiconductor material. If charge is collected by a reverse-biased PN junction, it produces a transient current. In bulk CMOS, source and drain regions form junctions with the transistor body, so a strike near these regions can create a current pulse that perturbs a connected signal.

The effect is localized, but its consequences may not be. A disturbance on a bias node, for example, can propagate through connected analog circuitry. The size and duration of the resulting error depend on factors including the strike location, device geometry, and circuit bias. This makes the physical behavior of charge collection relevant to circuit-level hardening decisions.

Another important mechanism is charge sharing. When a particle strikes near multiple devices, each may collect part of the generated charge. This can produce related transient currents on more than one circuit path. SNACC uses this behavior as part of its strategy for cancelling the disturbance at a protected node.

How SNACC performs charge cancellation

SNACC adds circuitry around a sensitive node to counteract the current caused by a particle strike. Its pull-up and pull-down networks address transient currents associated with NMOS and PMOS devices, respectively. Charge sensors are positioned to collect charge alongside the protected devices, and a current mirror redirects the sensor-path current toward the sensitive node.

The aim is for this compensation current to arrive at approximately the same time as the unwanted transient and carry a similar amount of charge. When the two currents are closely matched, the disturbance at the node can be reduced. In this sense, SNACC uses one event-related current to oppose another.

Matching is not perfect: charge collection can differ between the protected device and its sensor, and the current mirror introduces some delay. A further limitation is that the sensors themselves add sensitive area. If a sensor collects substantially more charge than the protected device, the resulting compensation may overcorrect the node or even introduce a transient that would not otherwise have occurred.

Enhanced SNACC: sensing, driving, and feedback

ESNACC changes the compensation strategy. Rather than relying on the charge collected by a sensor to determine the size of the correction current, it uses the sensor to trigger a current driver. A voltage feedback controller then monitors the protected node and controls a gating transistor to limit how long compensation is applied.

From detected charge to controlled recovery

In the described implementation, charge-sensing transistors are placed near devices that could disturb the sensitive node. When collected charge shifts the sensor signal past its switching level, the current driver activates. The gating transistor allows that current to act on the node, rapidly moving its voltage back toward its nominal value.

As the node approaches recovery, the voltage feedback controller turns off the gate. This prevents the driver from continuing to compensate after the disturbance has been addressed. The protected circuit can then settle through its own current drive. The pull-down network operates in a corresponding way for the opposite transient polarity.

This arrangement separates the roles of detection and correction: the sensors indicate that an event has occurred, while the driver supplies the recovery current. Because the correction current does not need to match the sensor current, ESNACC does not require the original SNACC approach’s matching strategy or its differential charge cancellation layout.

What the simulations indicate

The reported evaluation used Cadence Spectre, a 180 nm bulk CMOS process design kit, and a bias-dependent single-event model. Simulations examined strikes at different locations near a protected transistor and its charge sensors. In the tested cases, the response showed a faster recovery slope when the current driver activated, followed by the feedback controller turning off the gating transistor as the node neared its nominal voltage.

At the bias circuit output, the reported integral-square-error energy was reduced by approximately a factor of two compared with the unhardened circuit. Integral-square-error combines transient amplitude and duration into one measure of deviation from a reference voltage. The simulated results also indicated that direct strikes on the charge sensors produced negligible transients in the tested arrangement, unlike the concern identified for the original SNACC implementation.

These results are simulation-based evidence for the concept, not a substitute for validation in a fabricated design. Applying ESNACC requires circuit-specific work, particularly in designing the voltage feedback controller and selecting switching thresholds appropriate to the sensitive node’s nominal voltage and expected signal range.

Practical implications for circuit designers

For engineers considering single-event transient mitigation, ESNACC illustrates how feedback can address a hardening circuit’s own vulnerability. The technique is intended to keep charge-sensor activity from unnecessarily disturbing the protected node, while retaining an active recovery path when a genuine transient occurs.

  • Identify the critical node: Determine which circuit voltages can cause consequential downstream errors.
  • Account for charge collection: Consider nearby devices and strike location, rather than treating each junction as isolated.
  • Design the feedback for the application: Controller behavior and thresholds depend on the node’s operating point and signal swing.
  • Evaluate more than peak voltage: Transient duration and integral-square-error can help characterize circuit-level impact.

Conclusion

ESNACC builds on SNACC’s use of charge sensing but replaces matched-current cancellation with a triggered driver controlled by voltage feedback. The approach aims to shorten SET recovery while limiting the sensitive-area penalty associated with the original sensor arrangement. Its reported 180 nm simulations show reduced error energy for the evaluated bias circuit, while also highlighting the need for application-specific controller design and further validation. For radiation-sensitive analog and mixed-signal electronics, it offers a design concept for protecting critical nodes without allowing the mitigation circuitry to become an uncontrolled source of disturbance.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author