Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

The tariff impact on manufacturing depends on more than whether domestic producers gain protection from imported goods. Tariffs can also increase the cost of imported materials and components, while retaliatory measures can make U.S. products less competitive in overseas markets. For manufacturers operating through global supply chains, these effects can occur at the same time—and can pull business outcomes in different directions.

An analysis by Federal Reserve Board economists Aaron Flaaen and Justin Pierce examined U.S. manufacturing industries’ exposure to the 2018 tariff increases and trading partners’ retaliatory tariffs. Its central finding is relevant to plant managers, operations leaders and industrial decision-makers: the potential benefits of import protection did not necessarily outweigh the costs borne elsewhere in the production and sales chain.

Three channels shape the tariff impact on manufacturing

To distinguish the ways tariffs could affect manufacturers, the analysis measured three forms of industry exposure. Rather than treating tariffs as a single change in trade conditions, it considered how they might influence domestic competition, production costs and export access.

  • Import protection: Tariffs on competing imported products may give domestic producers room to compete more effectively in the U.S. market.
  • Higher input costs: When tariffs apply to imported materials or components used in production, manufacturers face increased costs. That pressure can affect production for both domestic and export markets.
  • Foreign retaliation: Trading partners’ tariffs on U.S. exports can make affected products less competitive in those overseas markets.

This framework matters because an industry may be protected on the output side while being exposed to tariffs on the inputs it needs. Exporting manufacturers may face an additional challenge if overseas customers encounter retaliatory tariffs on their goods.

What the industry-level analysis found

The researchers compared monthly outcomes in industries with differing exposure to these tariff channels. They examined manufacturing employment, industrial production and producer prices, accounting for the three channels together. This approach helped separate their estimated relationships rather than attributing an industry’s outcome to just one type of tariff exposure.

Industries more exposed to tariffs experienced relative declines in employment. Higher input costs and foreign retaliation were associated with negative employment effects, while import protection was associated with a small positive effect. Taken together, the estimated negative effects outweighed the positive contribution from import protection.

For an interquartile shift in exposure across the three channels, the researchers estimated a relative employment reduction of 1.4 percent. Their breakdown attributed a positive 0.3 percent contribution to import protection, compared with negative contributions of 1.1 percent from rising input costs and 0.7 percent from retaliation. These are relative estimates comparing more- and less-exposed industries; they are not a measure of the total economy-wide effect.

The results also linked higher exposure to input-cost tariffs with relative increases in producer prices. An interquartile increase in exposure to this channel was associated with a 4.1 percent increase in factory-gate prices. The analysis found little evidence of a relationship between the three tariff channels and industrial production during the period studied.

Why supply chain exposure matters

For manufacturers, an input tariff can work through a business’s bill of materials, not just through the price of a finished product competing on the market. If tariffed materials or components are part of production, the resulting cost pressure may affect the manufacturer’s ability to compete—even where tariffs also limit competing imports.

The study’s input-cost measure used industry input-output data to estimate the share of costs exposed to new tariffs. This illustrates why assessing supply-chain exposure requires looking beyond direct imports. A manufacturer may purchase an input from a domestic supplier that itself relies on imported materials, or use imported components as part of a product assembled in the United States.

Retaliation creates a different exposure: a business can face reduced competitiveness in export markets even if its domestic market position is unchanged. For manufacturers with international customers, tariffs affecting exported products therefore belong in the same assessment as tariffs affecting production inputs.

How to interpret the findings

The estimates describe short-run differences between industries with higher and lower exposure to the measured tariff channels, with outcomes observed through August 2019. They do not account for all economy-wide effects, and they do not establish that every manufacturer or industry experienced the same result. The authors also note that longer-term outcomes could differ as companies adjust suppliers, production locations or other elements of their operations.

Timing and product coverage matter, too. The analysis focuses on realized tariff changes and does not directly estimate the effects of uncertainty about future trade policy. Nor should its results be read as a forecast for later tariff actions: the consequences depend in part on whether affected products are production inputs, competing finished goods or exports exposed to retaliation.

Practical implications for industrial decision-makers

When evaluating trade-policy exposure, manufacturers can usefully map each relevant product and supplier against three questions:

  1. Could tariffs change the competitive position of the products we sell in the domestic market?
  2. Do tariffed imported materials or components contribute to our production costs, directly or through suppliers?
  3. Could retaliatory tariffs affect the competitiveness of our products in export markets?

These questions do not predict the effects of any particular policy change, but they help prevent an incomplete assessment that considers only protection from foreign competition. The broader lesson from the 2018 analysis is that global supply-chain connections can transmit tariff costs through manufacturing, influencing employment and producer prices even when a policy is intended to support domestic industry.

Conclusion: Tariffs can provide domestic manufacturers with protection, but that benefit may be offset by more expensive inputs and barriers to exports. For technical and business leaders, a sound exposure assessment should consider the full path from purchased materials to finished goods and overseas customers. The net effect depends on how those channels combine within each industry.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author