Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Renewable energy zoning can shape project feasibility just as strongly as equipment selection. A 2018 proposed text amendment to the Tallmadge Charter Township Zoning Ordinance in Michigan outlined requirements for wind energy turbines, solar systems, biofuel production and anaerobic digesters. For engineers, project developers and facility operators, the proposal illustrates how land-use rules can affect system location, design documentation, utility coordination and end-of-life planning.

The amendment was introduced and received its first reading on September 11, 2018, with a second reading scheduled for October 9. The notice described it as a proposed ordinance; the material does not establish whether or when it was ultimately adopted. Its provisions should therefore be understood as the contents of that proposal, not as confirmation of current requirements.

Renewable energy zoning and project planning

The proposal’s stated purpose was to encourage compatible renewable energy uses while protecting public health, safety, welfare and quality of life. It aimed to establish rules for siting, design, engineering, installation, operation and maintenance. In practical terms, that means a project team would need to consider more than generation capacity: parcel characteristics, neighboring uses, setbacks, noise, safety, access and removal obligations could all influence the design.

The text also proposed changes to the Planning Commission review period, plan-copy requirements and the method of notifying property owners about zoning violations. It does not provide the revised review period or the number of plan copies, so those details cannot be inferred from the notice.

Wind turbine zoning: categories, permits and safeguards

The proposal defined three wind system categories: small structure-mounted turbines, small tower-mounted turbines and medium wind energy turbines. Structure-mounted systems were limited to a maximum height of 15 feet; small tower-mounted turbines to 120 feet; and medium turbines to 150 feet. The rules for each category depended on its classification and location.

Small structure-mounted turbines were listed as permitted uses in all zoning districts, subject to a building permit and specified standards. Small tower-mounted turbines were permitted in the Agricultural District and treated as special uses in other districts. Medium turbines were proposed as special uses in designated districts, including agricultural, commercial, industrial, planned unit development and certain condominium districts.

Requirements addressed both physical design and operational risk. Examples included:

  • Minimum ground clearance for moving blades and components, restrictions on guy wires, and limits on vibration beyond the lot.
  • Noise limits tied to the ordinance’s existing sound provisions, along with requirements for braking or governing systems unless the manufacturer certified that braking was unnecessary.
  • Underground routing for specified electrical components, utility review for grid-connected systems, and measures to prevent communication-signal interference.
  • Setbacks from property lines, roads, occupied buildings and overhead utility lines, with requirements varying by turbine class.

Applications for larger medium turbines called for detailed site plans and supporting documentation. The proposal listed items such as turbine specifications, engineering information, noise and shadow-flicker assessments, maintenance and operations plans, insurance, utility interconnection evidence and a decommissioning plan. It also required analysis of shadow flicker at certain occupied buildings and buildable areas, with a proposed maximum of 30 hours per year at a building.

Solar, biofuel and anaerobic digester provisions

Solar installations

The proposal distinguished small-scale solar, intended to serve the building where it is installed, from large-scale solar intended to provide energy for off-site consumption. Small-scale systems could serve on-site users, while collective solar arrangements and sales of excess electricity through net billing or net metering were not prohibited by that provision.

Building-integrated photovoltaic and solar-thermal systems were proposed as permitted in all zoning districts. Rooftop and building-mounted collectors were also permitted, provided their height was reasonably necessary and they did not obstruct solar access to neighboring properties. Ground-mounted collectors were treated as accessory structures subject to district setbacks, screening and a condition that they not shade adjacent property during daylight hours. The proposal also addressed installation by a qualified solar installer, utility inspection for grid connections, battery enclosures and removal of systems that ceased their intended function for more than 12 consecutive months.

Biofuel facilities and digesters

Farm-based biofuel facilities producing up to 100,000 gallons annually were described as permitted uses if they met conditions including a 100-foot separation from property under different ownership, at least 25% of feedstock produced on the farm, and at least 25% of the fuel or another facility output used there. A separate at-home provision covered production up to 1,000 gallons per registered passenger vehicle or light truck, with parcel-size, building-separation, use and operating-plan conditions.

Anaerobic digester facilities were subject to a requirement that more than half of annual feedstock come from the host farm. The proposal also specified isolation distances from waters, water tables, wellhead protection areas and non-farm residences, and required operator training and certification under Michigan provisions. Digestate application to soils was to follow the cited agricultural management practices.

Decommissioning is part of the system lifecycle

For wind turbines, the proposal generally required decommissioning within 12 months after the end of useful life, which could be presumed after a continuous year without electricity generation. Medium turbine removal provisions covered associated structures and electrical components, foundation removal to a specified depth, site stabilization and, in some cases, access-road removal. Where the turbine was not owned by the property owner, an irrevocable letter of credit for decommissioning costs was required by the proposed text.

These provisions make lifecycle planning a permitting issue, not an afterthought. Project teams would need to identify who is responsible for removal, how funds will be secured and how the site will be restored.

Practical implications for project teams

The Tallmadge proposal demonstrates why renewable energy projects should be screened against local land-use rules early. System classification can determine whether a project is a permitted or special use, while parcel layout and neighboring properties affect setbacks, screening and impact analysis. Teams should also coordinate permitting documents with electrical design, utility interconnection, operational safety and decommissioning plans.

Because the document describes a proposal from 2018, anyone evaluating a project in Tallmadge should verify the ordinance currently in force and consult the appropriate township authorities. The broader lesson for technical decision-makers is to treat zoning review as an integrated part of project engineering: confirm the applicable rules before finalizing site selection, equipment specifications or construction plans.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author