Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

For industrial automation engineers, system integrators and operations leaders, financial results are not a substitute for plant-level demand data. They can, however, provide context for the conditions facing suppliers, customers and capital-intensive industries. FactSet’s July 31, 2020 snapshot of S&P 500 earnings Q2 2020 presented a mixed picture: steep year-over-year declines, a high share of companies beating estimates and early upward revisions to third-quarter forecasts.

The figures were preliminary. At the time, 63% of S&P 500 companies had reported second-quarter results, so blended earnings and revenue figures combined actual results with estimates for companies that had not yet reported. That distinction matters when interpreting the numbers: an earnings surprise measures performance against expectations, while year-over-year growth compares results with the same period a year earlier.

How to read the Q2 2020 earnings scorecard

The blended year-over-year earnings decline stood at 35.7%, while blended revenue was down 9.6%. If those rates held as reporting continued, the earnings decline would be the largest for the index since the fourth quarter of 2008, and the revenue decline the largest since the third quarter of 2009.

At the same time, 84% of companies that had reported posted earnings per share (EPS) above the mean analyst estimate. Sixty-nine percent reported revenue above estimates. In aggregate, reported earnings were 21.8% above estimates and revenues were 2.4% above estimates. FactSet noted that, if final, these surprise percentages would set records in its tracking history, which began in 2008.

These measures answer different questions. A company can beat a forecast that has already been reduced and still report results far below the prior year. For decision-makers, the takeaway is not that the quarter was strong overall, but that actual results were often better than the already-changed expectations analysts had set.

Sector results showed uneven exposure

The index-wide totals concealed substantial differences among sectors. Utilities was one of two sectors reporting year-over-year earnings growth, with a blended increase of 4.9%. Information Technology led revenue growth, at 3.7%. By contrast, Energy reported the steepest earnings decline, at 165.5%, and the largest revenue decline, at 50.0%. Industrials reported an 86.1% earnings decline and a 25.3% revenue decline.

Within Industrials, the Airlines industry was a major contributor to the earnings decline. Excluding its five companies, the sector’s blended earnings decline would have been 40.4%, rather than 86.1%. This illustrates why sector-level figures need context: a concentrated weakness in one industry can significantly affect a broader category.

For automation businesses, these figures provide a broad economic backdrop, not a direct measure of equipment orders, factory utilization or project pipelines. The report does not establish how any individual manufacturer’s automation spending changed. It does show why sector and industry composition matter when interpreting high-level indicators that may inform commercial planning.

Analyst revisions pointed to a change in direction

During July, analysts increased the S&P 500’s bottom-up EPS estimate for the third quarter by 1.1%, from $31.78 to $32.13. That was notable because estimates typically fell during the first month of a quarter: the average decline over the previous five years was 2.8%. The increase was the first first-month rise since the first quarter of 2018, when the estimate climbed 4.9%.

That improvement followed a much larger reduction. Between March 31 and June 30, the Q3 estimate had fallen 23.6%, from $41.60 to $31.78. The July increase therefore represented a modest reversal in the direction of estimates, not a return to the earlier forecast level.

Six sectors recorded increases in their Q3 bottom-up EPS estimates during July, led by Energy, Consumer Discretionary and Financials. Five sectors saw declines, with Industrials leading the decreases. Meanwhile, the blended Q2 earnings decline narrowed from 44.1% at June 30 to 35.7% in the July 31 report, reflecting upward revisions and positive surprises across several sectors.

Guidance and valuation added further context

Only 32 S&P 500 companies had issued Q3 EPS guidance at the time of the report. Of these, 25 provided positive guidance and seven negative guidance. That count needs to be read alongside the broader uncertainty recorded in the report: 51 companies had confirmed that they had withdrawn or were not providing annual EPS guidance for 2020 or 2021 during the Q2 earnings season, through July 28.

Analysts projected further year-over-year earnings declines for Q3 and Q4 2020, followed by growth in Q1 2021. Those were forecasts, not reported outcomes. The index’s forward 12-month price-to-earnings ratio was 22.0, above its five-year average of 17.0 and ten-year average of 15.3. This valuation measure describes the relationship between market price and expected earnings; it does not indicate the operating outlook for a particular industrial company.

Practical implications for industrial decision-makers

The July scorecard highlights three useful distinctions for interpreting market data:

  • Separate actual performance from forecast comparisons. Positive surprises can occur alongside sharp year-over-year declines.
  • Look below index-level averages. Sector and industry results varied widely, and one industry could materially influence a sector’s total.
  • Track revisions and guidance as well as reported results. Forecasts were changing, while many companies were not providing full-year guidance.

For operations and investment planning, the report is best treated as historical context from a specific point in 2020—not as a forecast for an individual business or a substitute for customer, supplier and sector-specific information. Its central message is that severe contraction and better-than-expected reported results can coexist. Understanding that tension, and distinguishing estimates from actuals, helps decision-makers read economic signals with appropriate caution.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author